7 Foods That Defined Thanksgiving in the 1960s and Rarely Make the Table Now

Thanksgiving in the 1960s had a look and a taste all its own. The turkey was the star, of course, but the table around it was crowded with dishes that came from the pages of women’s magazines, the backs of soup cans and the recipe boxes of mothers who had learned to cook during the Depression and the war years.

Many of those dishes were proudly made from convenience products that felt modern and exciting at the time. Others were old-fashioned favorites that families had served for generations. Ask anyone who grew up in that decade, and they’ll likely remember at least a few of them sitting in cut-glass bowls on a lace tablecloth.

Some of those foods have held on, but plenty have quietly slipped off the menu. Here are seven Thanksgiving dishes that defined the 1960s table and are rarely seen today.

Joyful ladies in vintage dresses in a retro kitchen
Image Credit: Deposit Photos

1. The Relish Tray

Before anyone sat down to eat, there was the relish tray. This long, divided glass dish held celery sticks, carrot curls, radish roses, black and green olives, sweet pickles and sometimes pickled watermelon rind. Kids would sneak olives onto their fingertips and wave them around before a grown-up told them to stop.

The relish tray was a sign that the hostess had gone the extra mile. Cutting radishes into roses and carrots into curls took time, and the tray stayed on the table throughout the meal. Today, many families skip it entirely or replace it with a cheese board or a veggie platter with ranch dip.

2. Molded Gelatin Salads

No 1960s Thanksgiving was complete without at least one shimmering gelatin mold. Lime Jell-O with cottage cheese and pineapple, cranberry gelatin with chopped celery and walnuts, and orange gelatin with shredded carrots were all common. They were turned out of fancy copper or aluminum molds and set on a bed of lettuce.

Gelatin salads were a point of pride for many home cooks, and recipe booklets from brands like Jell-O encouraged endless variations. The gelatin salad had been growing in popularity since the early 20th century, and by mid-century it was everywhere. Most of today’s younger guests would be puzzled by a savory gelatin salad.

3. Creamed Onions

Small white pearl onions bathed in a rich cream sauce were a classic side dish on many 1960s Thanksgiving tables, especially in New England and the Midwest. Some cooks peeled fresh pearl onions by hand, which was tedious work, while others used jarred or frozen onions to save time.

Creamed onions had a gentle sweetness that paired well with turkey and gravy. They were often seasoned with a little nutmeg or white pepper. These days, they’ve largely disappeared from family menus, replaced by roasted vegetables and more modern sides. For many people over 60, though, the smell of creamed onions still means Thanksgiving.

4. Candied Sweet Potatoes With Marshmallows

Sweet potato casserole topped with marshmallows wasn’t new in the 1960s, but it was at its height then. Canned yams were mashed or sliced, layered with brown sugar and butter, and covered with a blanket of marshmallows that turned golden in the oven.

The dish is still around in many homes, so it hasn’t vanished entirely. But many families have switched to a pecan streusel topping or simple roasted sweet potatoes instead. The old version, made with canned yams in heavy syrup and a thick marshmallow layer, is much less common than it was when boomers were kids.

5. Oyster Stuffing

In many parts of the country, especially along the East Coast and in the South, oyster stuffing was a beloved part of the holiday meal. Oysters were mixed with bread cubes, butter, celery, onions and seasoning, then baked inside the turkey or in a separate dish.

Oysters were once cheap and plentiful in America, and they appeared in all kinds of everyday dishes. As prices rose and tastes changed, oyster stuffing became a rarity. Today, most families stick to plain bread stuffing or cornbread dressing, and many younger guests have never tasted the oyster version at all. Stuffing in general is still beloved, of course, and it was recently named the favorite side in 38 states.

6. Waldorf Salad

Waldorf salad was a fixture on fancy holiday tables for decades. The classic version mixed chopped apples, celery and walnuts in mayonnaise, sometimes with grapes or raisins added. It was served on lettuce leaves and felt elegant thanks to its connection to New York’s famous Waldorf-Astoria Hotel.

The salad dates back to the 1890s, and by the 1960s it was a standard part of many Thanksgiving spreads. It offered a crisp, cool contrast to all the rich, hot dishes. Today it’s far less common, though some families still make it out of tradition, often with a lighter dressing than the old mayonnaise-heavy version.

7. Mincemeat Pie

Pumpkin pie has always ruled Thanksgiving, but in the 1960s it often shared the dessert table with mincemeat pie. Mincemeat was a dark, rich filling made from chopped dried fruit, apples, spices, suet and sometimes a bit of meat. Many families bought it in jars, like the well-known None Such brand, to save time.

Mincemeat pie had deep roots in English and early American cooking. Grandparents loved it, but many kids found it too strong and spicy. As older generations passed on, fewer families kept making it, and it’s now one of the rarest pies at Thanksgiving. If you’re curious which pies still make the cut, here’s a look at the Thanksgiving pies Americans serve today.

Why These Dishes Faded

Tastes change over time, and Thanksgiving menus are no exception. Many of these dishes were tied to convenience products and recipe trends that peaked in the mid-20th century. As fresh produce became easier to find year-round and food magazines started promoting new flavors, families began swapping out the old standbys.

Smaller families and busier schedules also played a role. A Thanksgiving with a relish tray, two gelatin salads, creamed onions and three kinds of pie took a lot of work. Many modern hosts prefer a shorter menu with dishes they know everyone will eat. Plenty of other faded traditions have changed over the years too.

Bringing Back a Little Nostalgia

Some families are bringing one or two of these dishes back as a nod to their parents and grandparents. A small relish tray or a molded salad on the table can spark wonderful conversations about Thanksgiving memories from decades ago.

Which of these 1960s Thanksgiving foods do you remember from your childhood table? And is there one you’d like to see make a comeback this year?

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *