8 Unpopular Opinions About Thanksgiving Many Americans Quietly Agree With
Thanksgiving is one of America’s most beloved holidays. It’s a day of family, gratitude, football and, above all, food. Most people wouldn’t dream of saying a bad word about it, at least not out loud. After all, who wants to be the person who complains about turkey and pie?
But behind closed doors, plenty of Americans have a few opinions about Thanksgiving that they rarely share. Maybe they secretly don’t like turkey, or they think the meal takes far too long to cook. Maybe they’d rather spend the day on the couch than drive across the state to see relatives.
These opinions might stir up debate at the dinner table, but you might be surprised how many people quietly agree. Here are eight unpopular opinions about Thanksgiving that many Americans share, even if they keep them to themselves.

1. Turkey Isn’t That Great
This is the most common unpopular Thanksgiving opinion of all. Plenty of people find turkey dry, bland and overrated. They’d much rather have ham, roast beef, prime rib or even fried chicken as the main dish.
Turkey is the traditional star of the Thanksgiving table, but many people say they eat it only because it’s expected. They load it up with gravy and cranberry sauce to give it flavor. Some families have even started serving a ham alongside the turkey, or replacing it altogether. For many, the side dishes are the real reason to look forward to the meal.
2. The Side Dishes Are Better Than the Main Event
Many Americans quietly believe the side dishes are the best part of Thanksgiving. Stuffing, mashed potatoes, sweet potato casserole, macaroni and cheese and green bean casserole often get more love than the turkey itself.
Some people fill their plates almost entirely with sides and take only a small slice of turkey. It’s not hard to see why. The side dishes come in so many flavors and textures, and they’re often the recipes families hold most dear. Stuffing alone was recently named the favorite side in 38 states.
3. Pumpkin Pie Is Overrated
Pumpkin pie is the classic Thanksgiving dessert, but not everyone loves it. Many people find it bland or prefer other desserts entirely. Pecan pie, apple pie, sweet potato pie and chocolate cream pie all have devoted fans who would happily skip the pumpkin.
Some people say they eat pumpkin pie only because it’s tradition, and they’d rather have a slice of cake or a plate of cookies. Others love the whipped cream more than the pie underneath it. It’s one of the most divisive desserts of the season. There are plenty of other Thanksgiving pies to choose from.
4. Cranberry Sauce From the Can Is Better
Food magazines and cooking shows love to praise homemade cranberry sauce, with whole berries, orange zest and spices. But many Americans quietly prefer the jellied cranberry sauce that slides out of the can in one piece, ridges and all.
For them, the canned version is pure nostalgia. It’s what they grew up eating, and no homemade sauce can replace it. Some families serve both to keep everyone happy, but the canned version often disappears first.
5. The Day Is Too Much Work
Many people who host Thanksgiving secretly feel the day is too much work. Cooking a huge meal, cleaning the house, setting the table and washing dishes for a crowd can be exhausting. Some hosts spend days preparing for a meal that’s eaten in under an hour.
That’s why more families are switching to potluck-style Thanksgivings, where everyone brings a dish. Others order prepared meals from grocery stores or restaurants. Some people even quietly wish they could skip the big meal altogether and just enjoy a relaxing day off. Many restaurants are open on Thanksgiving, which makes that easier.
6. Traveling for the Holiday Isn’t Worth It
Thanksgiving is one of the busiest travel times of the year. Airports are crowded, highways are jammed and flights are often delayed. Many Americans quietly feel the travel stress isn’t worth it, especially for a single meal.
Some people would rather stay home and celebrate with a small group, or visit family at a less hectic time of year. Others have started hosting “Friendsgiving” with local friends instead. While many people still make the trip, plenty admit they dread the journey. If you do travel, these carry-on suitcases can help.
7. Leftovers Are Better Than the Meal
Many people secretly look forward to the day after Thanksgiving more than the holiday itself. Leftover turkey sandwiches, reheated stuffing and a cold slice of pie for breakfast can be even more satisfying than the big meal.
The day after Thanksgiving is often more relaxed, with no cooking pressure and no crowded table. People can eat what they want, when they want. For many, the leftovers are the true reward for all the hard work of the holiday.
8. Christmas Decorations Can Go Up Before Thanksgiving
This one starts heated debates. Many people believe Christmas decorations shouldn’t go up until after Thanksgiving, out of respect for the holiday. But plenty of Americans quietly put up their tree and lights in early or mid-November.
For them, the holiday season is short, and they want to enjoy the decorations as long as possible. Some say Thanksgiving doesn’t have many decorations of its own, so why not get a head start on Christmas? It’s an opinion that can divide neighbors and families alike.
Why These Opinions Stay Quiet
Thanksgiving is closely tied to family traditions, and many people don’t want to hurt feelings by criticizing the meal or the customs. Saying you don’t like turkey at a table full of relatives who spent hours cooking it can feel rude. So many of these opinions stay unspoken.
But traditions evolve over time. Many families have already changed how they celebrate, whether it’s adding a ham, switching to a potluck or skipping the travel. These small changes often come from people finally sharing what they really think.
Making Thanksgiving Your Own
The best Thanksgiving is the one that works for your family. There’s no rule saying you have to serve turkey, travel across the country or make everything from scratch. What matters most is spending time with people you care about and taking a moment to be grateful.
Which of these unpopular opinions do you secretly agree with? And is there a Thanksgiving tradition you’d change if you could?
