Heating Oil Bills Could Jump 21% This Winter While Gas Heat Gets Cheaper, Government Forecast Says
As the first cold snaps settle in across the country, millions of Americans are bracing for their winter heating bills. Whether your home runs on natural gas, electricity, propane or heating oil can make a big difference in what you’ll pay between now and spring, and this year, the picture is decidedly mixed.
The U.S. Energy Information Administration, the federal agency that tracks energy prices, released its Winter Fuels Outlook in October. It forecasts lower bills for homes heated with natural gas and propane, but higher costs for homes that rely on electricity, and a steep increase for those that burn heating oil.
The numbers are averages, and every household is different. But they offer a useful look at what families across the country can expect from November through March. Here’s what the forecast says, fuel by fuel and region by region, and what it could mean for your home this winter.

Natural Gas: Bills Expected to Fall About 9%
Natural gas is the most common heating fuel in America, used as the main source of heat in roughly 46% of homes. The good news for those households is that the EIA expects average heating spending to drop about 9% this winter, to about $640 for the five-month season.
The main reason is lower prices. The EIA expects residential natural gas prices to average about 9% less than last winter. Homes in the Northeast and South could see the biggest declines, around 14% to 15%, while the West is the exception, with spending expected to rise about 7% because of colder weather forecast there.
Electricity: Bills Expected to Rise About 4%
About 43% of American homes are heated mainly with electricity, and many of them are in the South. For these households, the EIA expects average heating spending to rise about 4%, to roughly $1,196 for the winter.
The increase comes mostly from higher electricity prices, which the EIA expects to average about 18.2 cents per kilowatt-hour this winter, up about 3%. The West could see the biggest jump in spending, about 9%, while homes in the Northeast may see a small decline thanks to a milder forecast there. Electricity prices in the Northeast remain the highest in the country, at more than 26 cents per kilowatt-hour.
Heating Oil: The Biggest Increase by Far
Homes that burn heating oil face the toughest winter. The EIA expects average spending to jump about 21%, to roughly $2,115 for the season. That’s the highest cost of any major heating fuel.
The jump is driven by prices. The agency forecasts heating oil to average about $5.26 per gallon this winter, up about 34% from last year. Even though households are expected to use about 9% less oil because of a milder Northeast winter, the higher price more than wipes out those savings. About 4 million households use heating oil, and most of them are in the Northeast, especially in New England.
Propane: A Slight Decline
Propane heats about 5% of American homes, many of them in rural areas without access to natural gas lines. The EIA expects average propane heating costs to fall about 3%, to around $1,246 for the winter.
Propane prices are forecast to average about $2.52 per gallon, down about 2%. The Northeast could see the biggest drop, around 15%, while the Midwest, which has many propane-heated farmhouses and rural homes, may see a smaller decline of about 4%.
The Weather Is the Big Wild Card
All of these forecasts depend heavily on the weather. The EIA expects the country as a whole to be about as cold as last winter, with a milder Northeast, slightly colder South and a noticeably colder West. But a cold snap or a mild spell can change the math quickly.
The agency also noted that a strong El NiƱo pattern this winter could cause large swings in temperatures compared with its forecast. The EIA ran its numbers for a winter 10% colder than expected and one 10% warmer, and spending changes noticeably in both cases. In other words, these figures are a best guess, not a guarantee. A single week of bitter cold in January can add noticeably to a household’s bill, especially in homes that rely on oil or electric resistance heat.
Why Your Bill May Look Different
The EIA’s figures are national and regional averages. Your actual bill depends on the size and age of your home, how well it’s insulated, the efficiency of your furnace or heat pump, local utility rates and how warm you like to keep the house. Two neighbors with the same fuel can have very different bills. Homes with older, drafty windows or poor attic insulation tend to lose heat faster, while newer homes built to modern standards usually hold warmth much better.
It’s also worth remembering that the forecast covers only heating, not the rest of your utility bill. Lighting, appliances and hot water add to the total, and some utilities have raised delivery charges that aren’t reflected in fuel prices.
Keeping the House Warm for Less
Many households look for simple ways to stay comfortable without wasting heat. Common steps include sealing drafts around doors and windows, having the furnace checked, replacing filters and using a programmable thermostat. ENERGY STAR offers guidance on heating and cooling equipment, and this guide on how to winterize your home covers more ideas.
Older homeowners and families on tight budgets may qualify for help through the federal Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program, known as LIHEAP, which is run through state and local agencies. It’s also smart to prepare for winter storms, including knowing what to do in a power outage.
What It Means for Families This Winter
For the nearly half of American homes heated by natural gas, this winter may bring a bit of relief. For homes that depend on electricity, bills could creep higher, and for the households that burn heating oil, mostly in the Northeast, the forecast is a real concern. Many of those homes are older houses in small towns and rural areas, where switching fuels isn’t a simple or cheap option.
The EIA updates its forecast each month, so the numbers could shift as the season goes on. Either way, now is a good time to check your heating system, plan for higher bills if you use oil or electricity and make sure your home is ready for whatever winter brings.
