Lidl’s $34.40 Thanksgiving Basket Undercuts Walmart’s $35 Meal: How 7 Store Deals Compare

Thanksgiving dinner isn’t getting any cheaper. The American Farm Bureau says a classic dinner for 10 now costs about $58.63, with turkey up roughly 10% from last year. So it’s no surprise that the big grocery chains are fighting hard for holiday shoppers with bundled Thanksgiving meals at eye-catching prices.

Walmart, Lidl, Aldi and Target have all rolled out meal deals, and several regional grocers have joined in. The prices look similar at first glance, but the details are very different: some feed six people and some feed 10, some include dessert and some don’t, and one requires an app. Here’s how seven of this year’s deals compare.

Raw turkey on a board with ingredients
Image Credit: NewAfrica/Deposit Photos

1. Lidl: $34.40 for Up to 10 People

Lidl has the lowest price of the big national deals. Its Thanksgiving basket costs $34.40 and feeds up to 10 people, or about $3.44 a person, according to NBC Washington. It includes a Shady Brook Farms frozen turkey of up to 14 pounds, plus fixings for mashed potatoes, stuffing, green bean casserole, sweet potatoes, macaroni and cheese, cranberry sauce, dinner rolls and pumpkin pie.

There are conditions. The deal runs Nov. 11 through Nov. 25, shoppers have to scan the Lidl Plus app at checkout, and there’s a limit of one turkey per account. A bigger turkey raises the total. Lidl also says its basket won’t cost more than comparable bundles at Walmart or Aldi.

2. Walmart: $35 for 10 People

Walmart’s Holiday Meal Basket costs $35 and feeds 10, about $3.50 a person. It’s the biggest basket on the list, with 26 total items and 17 different products, including a Butterball turkey priced at 97 cents a pound.

The basket covers turkey and stuffing, mashed potatoes and gravy, green bean casserole, sweet potato casserole with mini marshmallows, corn casserole, and pumpkin pie with whipped topping. Walmart says this year’s basket has 18% more items than last year’s and costs 12% less for the same items. It’s available in stores and online through Dec. 24, with free express delivery on the basket through Nov. 30.

3. Aldi: Under $39 for 10 People

Aldi’s Thanksgiving list costs under $39 and serves 10. It includes a whole turkey, three boxes of stuffing mix, baby carrots, celery, fresh cranberries, sweet potatoes, Hawaiian rolls, two bags of frozen peas, pumpkin pie mix, pie crusts, whole milk and heavy whipping cream.

Aldi’s approach is a little more old-fashioned. Instead of boxed casseroles, it gives shoppers the raw ingredients for cranberry sauce from fresh berries and a homemade pumpkin pie. That appeals to cooks who like to make things from scratch, and Aldi lets shoppers add the whole list to an online cart with one click.

4. Target: $30 for 6 People

Target’s deal has the lowest sticker price at $30, but it feeds six people, not 10, so it works out to about $5 a person. The meal includes a Butterball whole turkey of up to 10 pounds, a 3-pound bag of russet potatoes, jellied cranberry sauce, two cans of green beans, cream of mushroom soup, French fried onions, stuffing mix, turkey gravy and two take-and-bake baguettes.

There’s no dessert in Target’s bundle, so families will need to pick up a pie separately. Target is also selling its Good & Gather frozen turkey for 79 cents a pound, one of the lowest per-pound turkey prices of the season.

5. Wegmans: Under $5 a Person for 8 People

Wegmans, the Northeast grocer, is offering a meal for eight that comes in under $5 a person, according to Fox 6 Milwaukee. It includes a 13-pound Shady Brook Farms turkey, gravy mix, stuffing, corn muffin mix, chicken stock, dinner rolls, canned corn, cranberry sauce, green bean casserole ingredients, potatoes, yams, macaroni and cheese and a frozen pumpkin pie.

6. Food Lion: Under $40 for 10 People

Food Lion, which has stores across the Southeast and Mid-Atlantic, has a meal for 10 under $40. It’s one of the most generous lists, with a 14-pound turkey, two boxes of stuffing, two boxes of deluxe macaroni and cheese, fresh cranberries, sweet potatoes, Hawaiian rolls, and both a frozen pumpkin pie and a frozen apple pie with whipped topping.

7. Price Chopper and Market 32: Under $40 for 10 People

In the Northeast, Price Chopper and Market 32 are offering a meal for 10 under $40, with a turkey of about 13.5 pounds, white and sweet potatoes, mini marshmallows, stuffing, gravy, green beans, King’s Hawaiian rolls, and the makings of a pumpkin pie. It’s a solid choice for families in New York and New England who want a traditional spread without driving to a big-box store.

What About a Bigger, Ready-Made Meal?

For families who want to skip cooking altogether, Sam’s Club is offering a ready-to-serve meal for 16 at about $158, with a hickory-smoked turkey, a boneless ham, sides, a charcuterie tray, rolls and two pumpkin pies. It’s a very different kind of deal, but it shows how wide the price range is this year.

How the Deals Compare With Buying Everything Yourself

Shoppers can usually beat these prices by shopping sales and using what they already have in the pantry. Many families already own spices, flour, butter and broth, which can make building their own meal cheaper than a bundle. Store-brand turkeys priced under $1 a pound, like Target’s Good & Gather and Walmart’s Butterball deal, are also a big part of what makes these baskets cheap.

The bundles are most useful for people who don’t want to plan, for first-time hosts, or for families who simply want one quick trip. They also make good donations: many churches and food pantries ask for complete Thanksgiving baskets, and a $35 bundle that feeds 10 goes a long way.

Which Deal Is Best?

On price per person, Lidl and Walmart are nearly tied at about $3.44 and $3.50, with Aldi close behind. Target’s bundle is cheapest up front but costs more per person and leaves out dessert. Shoppers who prefer cooking from scratch may like Aldi’s ingredient list, while families who want boxed shortcuts may prefer Walmart’s or Lidl’s.

The best choice may simply come down to which store is closest. Many shoppers also say the bundles are a good starting point rather than the whole meal, since most families have holiday table classics they won’t do without. Either way, with prices up across the board, a basket that feeds 10 for about $35 is a deal many households will be glad to see.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *