9 Foods That Got Their Names by Accident

Some food names are easy to explain. A hamburger is named after Hamburg, a sandwich after the Earl of Sandwich and a graham cracker after a preacher named Sylvester Graham. Others, though, came about through sheer luck, a passing comment or a story that took on a life of its own.

Many of America’s favorite snacks and dishes got their names in ways their creators never planned. A child’s nickname, a billboard spotted from a train window and a salesman’s excited reaction all played a part. Here are nine foods that got their names more or less by accident, along with a few stories that are more legend than fact.

Nachos with vegetables and cheese sauce
Image Credit: Shutterstock

1. Popsicle

The Popsicle traces back to Frank Epperson, who is said to have left a cup of soda with a stirring stick outside on a cold night in 1905, when he was 11 years old. The next morning, he found it frozen solid with the stick standing up in the middle. Years later, he began selling frozen treats on a stick and applied for a patent in 1923.

He first called them “Epsicles,” a mix of his last name and icicle. But his own children kept calling them “Pop’s ‘sicles,” since their father made them. That family nickname stuck, and the Popsicle name is still used today.

2. Twinkie

In 1930, James Dewar, a baker for the Continental Baking Company near Chicago, came up with a little sponge cake filled with cream. He needed a catchy name for the new snack. According to the company’s often-told story, he found it on a billboard advertising “Twinkle Toe Shoes” during a business trip.

Dewar shortened the name to Twinkie, and the snack became an American icon. The original filling was banana cream, but a banana shortage during World War II led the company to switch to vanilla. A shoe ad that most people have long forgotten gave the world one of its most famous snack cakes.

3. Cracker Jack

The caramel-coated popcorn and peanut mix that became Cracker Jack was sold by brothers Frederick and Louis Rueckheim in Chicago. As the company tells it, a salesman who tasted the treat in 1896 exclaimed, “That’s crackerjack!” The phrase was slang at the time for something excellent.

The brothers liked it so much that they trademarked the name. Prizes were later added to the boxes, and the snack earned a permanent spot in the song “Take Me Out to the Ball Game.” A single enthusiastic comment turned into one of the most recognizable brand names in America.

4. Pringles

Procter & Gamble introduced its stackable potato crisps in 1968. The company needed a name, and according to the brand’s history, it settled on Pringles after spotting Pringle Drive, a street in the Cincinnati area, in a phone book. The name had a nice ring to it and seemed fitting for the product.

There have been other theories over the years, but the phone book story is the one most often told. The crisps became famous for their saddle shape and tall can. Few people eating them today know their name may have come from an ordinary suburban street.

5. Nachos

Nachos were born in 1943 in Piedras Negras, Mexico, just across the border from Eagle Pass, Texas. According to the most common account, a group of women from a nearby U.S. military base came into a restaurant after the kitchen had closed. The maître d’, Ignacio “Nacho” Anaya, threw together fried tortilla pieces topped with cheese and jalapeños.

The women loved it and asked for “Nacho’s special.” The name was shortened over time, and the dish spread across Texas and then the rest of the country. A quick improvised snack ended up carrying a man’s nickname for generations.

6. Cobb Salad

The Cobb salad is named after Bob Cobb, who owned the famous Brown Derby restaurant in Hollywood. According to the restaurant’s story, he was hungry late one night in the 1930s and threw together leftovers from the kitchen. The mix included lettuce, avocado, tomato, bacon, chicken, hard-boiled egg and blue cheese.

Friends who tried it loved it, and the dish was added to the menu. It soon became a signature item and spread to restaurants nationwide. A late-night fridge raid turned into a menu classic named after the man who was simply looking for a snack.

7. Hush Puppies

Hush puppies are fried cornmeal balls that are a staple at Southern fish fries. The most popular story says cooks tossed scraps of fried batter to barking dogs while telling them to “hush, puppies.” That way, the dogs would be quiet while the fish cooked.

Food historians say the story is probably more legend than fact, and the true origin of the name isn’t clear. Still, it’s the tale most Southerners grow up hearing. Whether or not it’s true, it has helped make the name one of the most charming in American cooking.

8. Chimichanga

The chimichanga is a deep-fried burrito, and several restaurants in Arizona claim to have invented it. One popular story credits El Charro Café in Tucson, where the founder is said to have accidentally dropped a burrito into a pot of hot oil. She reportedly began to say a Spanish curse word but quickly changed it to “chimichanga” because children were nearby.

Like many food origin stories, this one is hard to prove, and other restaurants tell different versions. Still, the idea of an accidental burrito and a swallowed swear word has become part of the dish’s charm. Today, chimichangas are a staple of Tex-Mex and Southwestern menus.

9. Häagen-Dazs

The ice cream brand Häagen-Dazs sounds Scandinavian, but it was created in the Bronx, New York. Founder Reuben Mattus and his wife, Rose, launched the brand in 1960. According to the company, they made up the name to sound Danish because Denmark was associated with quality dairy products.

The name doesn’t actually mean anything in Danish or any other language. The umlaut over the “a” isn’t even used in Danish. It was a clever marketing choice that helped a small family ice cream business stand out in a crowded freezer aisle.

Why Food Names Matter

A good name can make or break a new food product. Companies today spend huge sums testing names with focus groups before a single box hits store shelves. In the past, though, names often came from much more casual moments.

Many of these stories have been retold so often that it’s hard to separate fact from legend. That’s part of the fun of food history, and it gives people something to talk about at the dinner table. For more food name stories, check out these American foods named after the places they come from.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *