8 Things Families Ordered at Friendly’s That Fans Still Miss

For millions of families on the East Coast and in the Midwest, Friendly’s was more than a restaurant. It was where you went after Little League games, on birthday nights and on Sunday afternoons when nobody felt like cooking. The booths were cozy, the waitresses were friendly and the ice cream was the main event.

Friendly’s started in 1935 as a tiny ice cream shop in Springfield, Massachusetts, founded by brothers Prestley and Curtis Blake. They sold double-dip cones for a nickel. By 1974, the chain had grown to about 500 restaurants across the Northeast, Mid-Atlantic and Midwest, and it became a beloved part of family life for generations.

Since then, the chain has shrunk a great deal, and many fans no longer have a Friendly’s anywhere near them. That’s why so many people get nostalgic when they think about their old orders. Here are eight things families ordered at Friendly’s that fans still miss.

Young Caucasian man with long curly hair smiling and reaching toward cheeseburgers and fries on table in diner, milkshake and soft drink with straws visible nearby
Young Caucasian man with long curly hair smiling and reaching toward cheeseburgers and fries on table in diner, milkshake and soft drink. Image Credit: Pressmaster/ Shutterstock

1. The Fribble

No Friendly’s memory is complete without the Fribble. This super-thick shake was so dense that it was hard to drink through a straw, and that was part of the fun. Kids would sit with their cheeks sucked in, trying to get a sip of chocolate, vanilla, strawberry or coffee Fribble.

According to the chain’s history, the shake was originally called the Awful-Awful, and it was renamed the Fribble in 1965. For many fans, the Fribble is the single thing they miss most. People who moved away from New England often say they can’t find a shake that compares.

2. The Clown Sundae

For kids, the clown sundae was the most exciting thing on the menu. A scoop of ice cream was topped with a sugar cone hat and decorated with candy to look like a clown’s face. It was served in a little dish that made children feel like the meal was made just for them.

Many people who grew up going to Friendly’s remember ordering the clown sundae at birthday dinners. It was simple, but it felt magical to a child. Parents loved it too, because it was an affordable treat that kept kids happy at the table.

3. The Big Beef

Before fancy burger chains were everywhere, Friendly’s served burgers that families loved. The Big Beef was one of the classics, a hearty cheeseburger served with fries and pickles. It was the go-to order for hungry dads and teenagers after a ball game.

Over the years, Friendly’s menu changed and updated its burger lineup, but many longtime fans remember the older burgers fondly. For people who grew up in the 1970s and 1980s, a Friendly’s burger and a Fribble was the perfect meal.

4. The Fishamajig

The Fishamajig, with its silly name, was a fried fish sandwich that kids loved to order just to say it out loud. It was served on a soft roll with tartar sauce, and it was a favorite on Friday nights, especially among Catholic families who avoided meat on Fridays.

The name alone has made the Fishamajig a nostalgic favorite. Many adults remember giggling as they ordered it as kids. It’s one of those menu items that shows the playful personality Friendly’s had in its heyday.

5. The Jim Dandy

For ice cream lovers who wanted something big, the Jim Dandy was the ultimate treat. This giant sundae featured several scoops of ice cream with a banana, multiple toppings, whipped cream, nuts and cherries. It was often shared by the whole table.

Ordering a Jim Dandy felt like a celebration. Families would gather around and dig in with long spoons, laughing as they tried to finish it. For many people, the Jim Dandy is linked to special memories like graduations, good report cards and birthday parties.

6. Patty Melts and Supermelts

Friendly’s was known for its grilled sandwiches, especially the Supermelt line. These sandwiches came on grilled bread with melted cheese and fillings like burgers, chicken or tuna. The patty melt, with its grilled onions and Swiss cheese on rye, was a classic diner-style favorite.

These hearty sandwiches were perfect for lunch with a side of fries and a Fribble. They gave Friendly’s a comfortable, homey feel, like a step up from a fast-food burger but still affordable. Many fans say they’ve never found a sandwich quite like it elsewhere. They’re among the diner classics Americans still crave.

7. The Wattamelon Roll

The Wattamelon Roll was a frozen ice cream treat made to look like a slice of watermelon. It had green and white outer layers with pink sherbet in the middle, dotted with chocolate chips to look like seeds. It was sold in restaurants and in grocery stores.

For many families, the Wattamelon Roll was a summer tradition. It showed up at backyard cookouts and Fourth of July parties. The colorful dessert brought a smile to every kid’s face, and adults loved it just as much.

8. Takeout Ice Cream by the Half-Gallon

Many families didn’t just eat at Friendly’s. They took the ice cream home. Friendly’s restaurants often had a takeout window or counter where you could buy ice cream to bring home, and its ice cream was also sold in supermarkets.

Bringing home a half-gallon of Friendly’s ice cream was a treat for the whole family. It meant ice cream sundaes at the kitchen table or a scoop after dinner. Even today, Friendly’s ice cream is sold in some East Coast supermarkets, which lets fans enjoy a taste of nostalgia.

Why So Many Friendly’s Closed

Friendly’s went through hard times over the past few decades. The company filed for bankruptcy in 2011 and closed 63 restaurants, then closed 37 more as it emerged in 2012. More closures came in 2019, including most locations in upstate New York and the last restaurants in Rhode Island and Virginia.

In 2020, the company filed for bankruptcy again during the pandemic and was sold. A new owner acquired about 130 locations in 2021. That’s a far cry from the chain’s peak, and many former customers now live hours from the nearest Friendly’s. It’s a familiar story for many family restaurants that struggled to keep up with changing times.

The Memories Live On

Even as the chain has shrunk, Friendly’s holds a special place in the hearts of millions. For many people, it represents childhood, family time and the simple joy of a sundae after dinner. The co-founders lived remarkably long lives too: Curtis Blake died in 2019 at 102, and Prestley Blake in 2021 at 106.

Did your family go to Friendly’s when you were growing up? And what was your go-to order, the Fribble, the clown sundae or something else?

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *