10 Christmas Party Foods From the 1970s That Would Puzzle Today’s Guests

Picture a living room in December 1975. The tree is covered in tinsel, a record of Bing Crosby is spinning on the console stereo, and the coffee table is crowded with platters that took the hostess most of the afternoon to put together. There is something wobbling, something on toothpicks, and something rolled in chopped nuts.

Those parties were a big deal. Neighbors dressed up, kids were allowed to stay up late, and the food was meant to impress. Many of the recipes came straight from women’s magazines, product boxes and church cookbooks, and they reflected a decade that loved convenience foods, gelatin and anything that could be speared on a frilly pick.

Bring a few of those dishes to a holiday party today, though, and you might get some confused looks. Here are ten Christmas party favorites from the 1970s that younger guests might not recognize, even though plenty of people who grew up with them still get nostalgic at the thought.

10 Christmas Party Foods From the 1970s That Would Puzzle Today's Guests
Image Credit: Shutterstock

1. The Cheese Ball Rolled in Nuts

No 1970s Christmas party was complete without a cheese ball. Cream cheese was mixed with shredded cheddar, a little Worcestershire sauce and sometimes a splash of port, then shaped into a ball and rolled in chopped pecans or walnuts. It sat in the middle of a plate surrounded by a ring of crackers.

Some hostesses shaped theirs into a log or even a pinecone, pressing sliced almonds into the surface to look like scales. Today’s guests are more likely to see a charcuterie board, but the cheese ball still has loyal fans who say nothing tastes more like Christmas.

2. Fondue Pots Bubbling on the Table

Fondue had a huge moment in American homes in the late 1960s and 1970s. The Swiss dish of melted cheese and wine, served in a communal pot, became a fashionable party centerpiece, and fondue sets were among the most popular wedding and Christmas gifts of the era, according to the history of fondue.

Guests stood around the pot with long, color-coded forks, dunking cubes of bread into the cheese. Dessert fondue with melted chocolate and chunks of fruit soon followed. Plenty of those orange and avocado-green pots are still sitting in basements, waiting for a comeback.

3. Cocktail Meatballs in Grape Jelly Sauce

Tell a younger guest that the sauce on the meatballs is made from grape jelly and chili sauce, and you will probably see some raised eyebrows. Yet this sweet-and-tangy combination was one of the most requested party recipes of the decade, often kept warm in a slow cooker or a chafing dish.

The recipe spread from kitchen to kitchen on handwritten cards, and it worked because it was cheap, easy and impossible to mess up. The meatballs were served with toothpicks so guests could grab one while holding a drink in the other hand, which made them perfect for a crowded living room.

4. Rumaki on Toothpicks

Rumaki was the height of party sophistication for many 1970s hosts. The appetizer usually combined chicken livers and slices of water chestnut, marinated in soy sauce, wrapped in bacon and broiled until crisp. The dish grew out of the mid-century tiki craze, which made “exotic” appetizers a fixture at American parties.

Chicken livers are not a common party food anymore, which is why rumaki would puzzle many guests today. Some modern cooks still make a version with dates or pineapple instead of liver, but the original remains a true taste of the era.

5. A Shimmering Gelatin Mold

Gelatin salads were everywhere in the 1960s and 1970s, and the holidays brought out the most ambitious versions. Red and green layers, canned fruit suspended in lime Jell-O, or a ring mold filled with cranberries and nuts all made appearances on the buffet table.

Some molds were savory, like tomato aspic studded with celery and olives. Hostesses unmolded them onto a plate lined with lettuce leaves and hoped they wouldn’t collapse on the way to the table. Today’s guests might enjoy the look, but many would be unsure whether the dish was a salad or a dessert.

6. Ham and Pickle Roll-Ups

In much of the Midwest, ham and pickle roll-ups were, and still are, a party essential. Thin slices of deli ham were spread with cream cheese, wrapped around a dill pickle spear and sliced into little pinwheels. Some families call them pickle wraps, while others have their own names for them.

They are simple, salty and oddly addictive, and they could be made the night before. Guests from other parts of the country often stare at them in confusion the first time they see them, but most end up reaching for a second one.

7. Watergate Salad

This fluffy green dish combined pistachio instant pudding, crushed pineapple, mini marshmallows, chopped nuts and whipped topping. It became popular in the mid-1970s, and the origin of its famous name is still debated, according to the history of Watergate salad.

Whatever the name’s story, the dish showed up at countless holiday potlucks and Christmas parties. Its pale green color made it look festive on a buffet table. Today’s guests might wonder whether it belongs with the side dishes or the desserts, and honestly, so did people back then.

8. Homemade Chex Party Mix

The original party mix recipe appeared on Chex cereal boxes in the 1950s, and by the 1970s, many families made huge batches every December. Cereal, nuts and pretzels were tossed with melted butter and Worcestershire sauce, then baked low and slow in the oven, filling the house with a savory smell.

The Chex mix was often packed into tins and given as gifts to neighbors and teachers. It wouldn’t confuse guests today, since bagged versions are sold everywhere. But the homemade kind, with its uneven bits of buttery cereal, is something many people say they haven’t tasted since childhood.

9. The Cheese and Pineapple Hedgehog

One of the more whimsical party pieces of the era was the cheese and pineapple “hedgehog.” A half grapefruit, a melon or a potato wrapped in foil served as the body, and it was covered in toothpicks, each topped with a cube of cheddar and a chunk of pineapple. Some versions added cocktail onions or olives.

It was part snack and part decoration, and kids loved pulling the toothpicks out one by one. This one is more associated with British parties, but plenty of American hostesses made similar displays with cheese cubes and fruit. Bring one to a party today, and expect guests to take photos before they take a bite.

10. Clam Dip With Potato Chips

Before spinach and artichoke dip took over, clam dip was the star of many holiday parties. Canned minced clams were mixed with cream cheese, a little lemon juice, Worcestershire sauce and garlic, then served with ridged potato chips. The dip had become famous on television in the 1950s and stayed popular for decades.

Many younger guests have never tried it, and the idea of seafood dip might take them by surprise. People who grew up with it, though, often say it’s the first thing they think of when they remember their parents’ parties.

Why These Dishes Still Bring Back Memories

Looking back, much of the food at 1970s Christmas parties had one thing in common: it was made at home by someone who wanted guests to feel welcome. Recipes were swapped between friends and neighbors, and many of them came from the backs of boxes and cans, as described in this look at 1970s kitchens.

If you want to throw a retro holiday party this year, a few of these dishes would make a fun conversation starter. Add some vintage decorations, put on an old Christmas album, and see how many guests remember the cheese ball. You might be surprised how quickly the stories start.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *