SNAP Recipients Say Their Benefits Were Drained Right Before Thanksgiving, and the Federal Fund to Replace Them Is Gone
For millions of families, the monthly SNAP deposit is what makes a holiday meal possible. That’s why a new wave of benefit theft reports is hitting so hard just days before Thanksgiving. Several residents in the Bronx told CBS New York that their November food benefits vanished within hours of landing on their cards, spent at stores they had never visited.
What makes this round of thefts especially painful is that, in most cases, the money is not coming back. A federal program that once let states replace stolen SNAP benefits ended nearly two years ago, and Congress has not renewed it. Here’s what happened, how the thefts work and what some states are doing to make cards harder to steal from.

What Bronx Residents Say Happened
According to CBS New York, several Bronx residents said their SNAP benefits disappeared just hours after being deposited in November. They reported multiple unauthorized transactions made at the same time on the same day at food stores in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens and Pennsylvania.
Some of the same stores showed up in the transaction histories of different recipients. The charges ranged from $92 to more than $1,000 and were made mostly at bodegas and delis, plus at least one BJ’s Wholesale Club in Middle Village, Queens. The NYPD’s 43rd Precinct confirmed it is investigating, and many of the residents said they have ordered new cards.
How SNAP Benefits Get Stolen
Most of these thefts happen through a scheme called skimming. Criminals attach a hidden device to a store’s card reader that copies the information from a card’s magnetic stripe. A small camera or fake keypad can capture the PIN at the same time.
With that information, thieves create cloned cards and drain the account, often right after benefits are deposited each month. Unlike most bank debit and credit cards, SNAP EBT cards in most states still rely only on magnetic stripes, which makes them easier to copy. That’s why lawmakers and advocates have been pushing for chip cards for years.
Why Victims Usually Can’t Get the Money Back
For a while, there was a safety net. Congress temporarily allowed states to replace SNAP benefits stolen through skimming and similar schemes, using federal money. But that authority expired on December 20, 2024, and it hasn’t been renewed.
As CBS New York reported, New York State can no longer accept replacement claims for SNAP benefits stolen after December 21, 2024. Only stolen cash assistance benefits are still eligible for reimbursement there. Because SNAP is primarily federally funded, restoring replacement for stolen food benefits would require action from Congress.
How Big the Problem Has Become
New York State Senator-elect Jessica Gonzalez-Rojas told CBS New York that EBT theft has been an issue since at least 2022. She said the outer boroughs of Queens, the Bronx and Brooklyn have been hit hardest, with stolen benefits across the state amounting to around $60 million to $65 million.
The problem isn’t limited to New York. In Texas, nearly 40,000 households have reported stolen benefits since May 2023, according to KVUE. In October, the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office announced it had indicted eight people accused of stealing more than $7 million in SNAP benefits, though that case has not been linked to the latest Bronx reports.
New York Is Switching to Chip Cards Early Next Year
There is some help on the way. New York State plans to roll out new chip-based EBT cards for SNAP recipients in the first three months of 2027. The state’s Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance says the change will “help protect SNAP recipients from benefit theft.”
Chip cards are much harder to clone because the chip creates a unique code for each transaction. CBS New York noted that, according to Visa, chip cards decreased fraud by 87% from 2015 to 2019. Several other states have already started moving their EBT cards to chips, and more are expected to follow.
Texas Lawmaker Files a Bill for Chip Cards Too
In Texas, State Sen. Judith Zaffirini filed Senate Bill 374 on November 13. As KPRC 2 reported, the bill would require the state’s Lone Star Cards to include security chips that let users insert or tap their cards instead of swiping them.
Under the proposal, Texas would start issuing chip-equipped cards by September 1, 2028, and every card in use would need the technology by March 1, 2029. The bill will be considered in the Texas Legislature’s 2027 session, which begins January 12. It would need approval from both chambers and the governor, and the cost of the upgrade hasn’t been determined yet.
A Federal Rule Is Also in the Works
The U.S. Department of Agriculture is also looking at the problem. In October, it published a proposed federal rule that would require states to move SNAP cards to chip and contactless payment technology, according to KPRC 2. The proposal would also add security requirements for online transactions and give recipients more tools to monitor their accounts.
That rule has not been finalized. If it moves forward, it could eventually make chip cards standard across the country. For now, though, most recipients are still using cards with magnetic stripes.
Steps Recipients Can Take to Protect Their Cards
State agencies recommend a few simple habits to reduce the risk. New York’s OTDA suggests inspecting card readers before swiping, looking for loose parts, bulky attachments or anything that seems out of place. Recipients are also encouraged to change their PIN regularly and check their transaction history often.
Many states also let users lock or freeze their EBT card through an app between shopping trips. States have also been changing what SNAP can buy, with some restricting prepared desserts and sweets. In New York, that’s done through the ebtEDGE app, and similar tools exist elsewhere. Recipients who notice charges they didn’t make should report them to their state agency right away and request a new card.
Why the Timing of Theft Matters
Thieves often strike right after benefits are deposited, because that’s when accounts have the most money. Many states load SNAP benefits on specific days of the month, and criminals using cloned cards can drain an account within hours. Recipients may not notice until they reach the checkout and their card is declined.
That timing is especially painful in November. Many families plan their Thanksgiving shopping around their benefit date, buying the turkey, potatoes and pie ingredients as soon as their funds arrive. When those funds disappear overnight, there’s often no backup plan for the holiday meal.
What This Means for Families This Holiday
For families who just lost a month of food benefits, the timing couldn’t be worse. Thanksgiving groceries are already expensive, and food banks across the country say demand is running high. Many victims are now relying on pantries, churches and relatives to fill the gap until next month’s deposit.
Advocates say the fix is clear: faster chip card rollouts and a renewed federal replacement program. Until then, the families hit hardest are the ones least able to absorb the loss. As Gonzalez-Rojas told CBS New York, some had even been saving their benefits for a special occasion, only to find a zero balance at the checkout.
