The Crispy Parmesan Potatoes That Might Upstage Everything Else on the Dinner Table
A pan of roasted potatoes is usually a safe side dish. Give those potatoes a golden Parmesan crust, though, and they start making a serious case for top billing. The appeal is easy to see: each small potato is tender inside, while the side pressed against the pan develops a browned layer of cheese that you reveal when you lift it out. No deep fryer is involved, and the ingredients are familiar enough for an ordinary dinner.
This is the Parmesan-crusted potato method that drew attention on social media, not a newly discovered recipe or a trick with one official inventor. Cookbook author and KaleJunkie creator Nicole Keshishian Modic shared a version that attracted more than 50 million views, according to her site and Good Morning America. Recipe developer Julia Levy has also published a version for Allrecipes. Their ingredient amounts and preparation differ, but both rely on the same satisfying move: roast halved potatoes cut-side down against a Parmesan mixture, then let the crust set before lifting them out.
The Crust Does the Heavy Lifting
Modic uses mini Yukon Gold potatoes, cutting them in half before making shallow diamond-shaped scores in the cut surfaces. She tosses the potatoes with olive oil, dried parsley, garlic powder, salt and pepper, then spreads a paste of melted butter and freshly grated Parmigiano-Reggiano in a baking dish. The potatoes go onto that layer cut-side down, where the cheese can brown against the dish as they roast. Her recipe calls for a 425°F oven and about 25 to 26 minutes of baking.
The cheese isn’t an incidental flourish in Modic’s version: her recipe calls for 1½ cups of freshly grated Parmigiano-Reggiano for one pound of mini potatoes. “Make sure it’s a BOATLOAD of parm,” she told followers in a comment highlighted by Good Morning America. That is a useful warning for anyone tempted to dust a little cheese over the potatoes and expect the same substantial crust. The cheese mixture is the surface the potatoes cook against, not merely a finishing sprinkle.
Levy’s Allrecipes version offers a smaller-scale alternative. It uses a 24-ounce package of baby Yukon Gold potatoes, two tablespoons of butter, half a cup of freshly grated Parmesan, garlic-and-herb seasoning, and salt. After melting the butter in a baking dish, the cook stirs in the cheese and seasoning to make a paste, spreads a little on each scored potato half, and bakes the potatoes cut-side down for about 25 minutes. It makes four servings, compared with the six servings listed for Modic’s version, so choose one recipe’s quantities rather than mixing the two at random.
Related: The Cozy Soup Formula You’ll Want on Repeat When Dinner Feels Impossible
A Few Minutes of Patience Matter
It is tempting to reach for a spatula the moment the pan comes out of the oven, especially when the edges look deeply golden. Both published methods ask you to wait. Levy’s recipe gives the potatoes five minutes before releasing them; Modic’s calls for 10 minutes so the cheese can harden. That pause is part of making the dish, not an optional delay while everyone else starts dinner.
A sturdy spatula helps lift each potato with its crust attached. In Levy’s method, look for tender potatoes and a golden Parmesan layer on the bottom before you remove the pan. Modic similarly calls for potatoes that are crispy and golden, followed by the rest before serving. Cook times are guides, not guarantees: potato size and oven performance can affect when the centers are tender and the cheese is browned.
Modic has addressed that variation in her recipe’s comment section. After one reader reported that the potatoes tasted good but did not become crisp in the suggested time, she replied, “Every oven is different and may require a different cook time.” The practical takeaway is to look at the potatoes and the crust, not just the clock. If the centers aren’t tender or the cheese hasn’t browned, the dish may need more time; if the cheese is already coloring quickly, keep a close eye on it.
Make Them Fit Your Dinner
These potatoes are easy to picture beside a roast, but they do not need a special occasion. Modic suggests serving her version as an appetizer, a side dish with a main course, or even a snack. That flexibility is part of the attraction: you can bring the whole pan to a casual meal or put the crisp halves on a platter where guests can see the cheese-crusted side.
The recipe also leaves room for flavor choices without changing its central technique. Levy seasons her Parmesan-butter paste with a garlic-and-herb blend, while Modic uses dried parsley, garlic powder, and black pepper. Another published version from Cooking With Ayeh includes parsley and red pepper flakes for a little heat. Whichever approach you choose, the essential steps remain the same: halve the potatoes, press their cut sides into a cheese-rich coating, and roast until tender and browned.
One note about the hype: Modic reported the big view count for her own recipe, but that does not mean every attempt will emerge with an identical crust. Her comments include both happy reports and readers who needed a longer cook time. That is a more useful expectation than a promise of instant perfection. Start with small potatoes, follow one tested method, give the Parmesan time to brown, and resist scraping up the results too soon; the side dish can handle the rest.
