5 Cowboy-Style Cheeseburger Toppings That Bring Big Flavor to the Table
A cheeseburger doesn’t need a towering stack of ingredients to impress. Sometimes, a crunchy onion ring, a spoonful of thick chili, or a little barbecue sauce is enough to turn an ordinary burger into the meal everyone remembers.
These toppings draw inspiration from Western-style burger combinations, not from claims about what working cowboys historically ate. Some lean into barbecue, bacon, and onions, while others bring Southwestern-inspired peppers and cheese.
The amounts are flexible starting points, so adjust them to suit your appetite. Pick the combination that sounds best, grab a few napkins, and let the burger be the star.
Crispy Onion Rings, Barbecue Sauce and Smoked Cheddar
A good burger has contrast, and this combination delivers it in every bite. Smoked cheddar adds richness, barbecue sauce brings a sweet, tangy layer, and onion rings add crunch. The idea has a recipe foundation, too. Food & Wine’s cowboy burgers combine onion rings, barbecue sauce, smoked cheddar, and bacon.
For an easy version at home, prepare frozen onion rings according to the package directions while you cook the patties. Add a slice of smoked cheddar to each burger, then spoon about a tablespoon of barbecue sauce on top. Finish with one or two onion rings just before serving.
Place the sauce beneath the rings instead of pouring it over the top. That gives the crispy coating a better chance of staying crunchy as the burger makes its way to the table. Want a topping that’s easier to bite through? Try ready-to-use crispy fried onions instead. They offer a thinner layer of crunch while keeping the same barbecue-and-cheese idea.
Related: 8 American Overpriced Foods That Aren’t Worth the Hype
Barbecue-Glazed Bacon and Grilled Onions
If onion rings aren’t your thing, grilled onions offer a softer alternative. Add bacon and cheddar, and you have a burger that leans into smoky, savory flavor without the fried coating. Serious Eats’ barbecue bacon burger pairs cheddar with grilled onions and bacon.
Its recipe recommends using onion slices about one-third of an inch thick so they hold together on the grill. For each burger, start with two cooked bacon strips, a few grilled onion pieces, and a slice of cheddar.
Brush the bacon lightly with barbecue sauce near the end of cooking, then layer it over the onions and melted cheese. The onions bring sweetness as they brown, while the bacon adds saltiness and crunch.
You don’t need a heavy sauce coating for this combination to work. No grill? Use a skillet to brown the onion slices and cook the bacon separately. Stack everything on your burger and bring the cookout feeling indoors.
Jalapeño-Popper Spread and Crispy Bacon
Jalapeño poppers disappear quickly from a snack table. Their creamy, spicy combination also makes an appealing inspiration for a cheeseburger topping.
Allrecipes’ cream cheese jalapeño hamburgers combine cream cheese and peppers in a stuffed patty. This version takes a different approach, turning the idea into a spread and adding bacon on top.
For four burgers, mix 4 ounces softened cream cheese with ¼ cup shredded cheddar and 1 tablespoon finely chopped, well-drained pickled jalapeños. Taste the mixture and add more peppers for a stronger kick.
Spread a modest spoonful over each hot burger, then finish with crumbled cooked bacon. The cream cheese adds tang, the jalapeños bring heat and a pickled bite, and the bacon adds a crisp finish. Finely chopping the peppers helps distribute them throughout the spread. Draining them first also keeps extra pickling liquid from making the mixture runny.
Roasted Poblanos, Pepper Jack and Chipotle Mayo
When you want peppers to play a bigger role, reach for poblanos. Roasted and cut into broad strips, they make a substantial topping that sits comfortably over melted cheese.
A Beef Loving Texans recipe pairs roasted poblanos with pepper jack and chipotle mayonnaise. It’s a useful starting point for a Southwestern-inspired burger.
Roast or broil the poblanos, turning them until their skins blister. Transfer them to a covered bowl to steam briefly, then remove the loosened skins, stems, and seeds. Cut the peppers into strips.
Melt pepper jack over each patty and add several strips of poblano. For a quick sauce, stir a little minced canned chipotle in adobo into mayonnaise, tasting as you go. Spread a thin layer on the bun. The peppers add a soft, savory layer, while the cheese and chipotle mayo bring more chile flavor. Start with a little sauce so the roasted poblanos still have room to shine.
Thick Chili, Cheddar and Pickled Jalapeños
Some burgers are made for a neat bite. A chili cheeseburger usually calls for extra napkins, and that’s part of its appeal. Food Network’s chili cheeseburgers pair cooked patties with cheddar and hot chili. Delish’s version adds pickled jalapeños as a finishing touch.
For a manageable homemade version, use about ¼ cup of thick chili per burger. Leftover or prepared chili can work. If it looks soupy, simmer it uncovered until it’s thick enough to spoon over the patty.
Add cheddar to the burger, spoon on the hot chili, and finish with a few drained pickled jalapeño slices. The peppers offer a sharp contrast to the rich beef, cheese, and chili.
Toast the bun and resist piling on too much. A smaller helping is easier to handle and leaves room to taste the cheeseburger underneath.
