6 Things to Know Before Buying Potatoes for Thanksgiving Mashed Potatoes

On Thanksgiving, the turkey may get the spotlight, but the mashed potatoes are often the first dish to disappear. A big, buttery bowl of them sits at the center of the table, ready to be topped with gravy and passed around again and again. For many families, they’re not optional.

Making great mashed potatoes starts long before the pot of water goes on the stove. It starts at the grocery store, where shoppers face bins and bags of russets, Yukon Golds, reds and more. Choosing the wrong potato, buying too few or picking a bag with hidden problems can make the job harder on the busiest cooking day of the year.

Before you head out on your big holiday grocery run, here are six things to know about buying potatoes for Thanksgiving mashed potatoes. A few minutes of planning can mean the difference between gluey and gloriously fluffy.

Mashed potatoes with butter in a white bowl on wooden rustic table.
Mashed potatoes with butter in a white bowl on wooden rustic table. Image Credit: Goskova Tatiana/ Shutterstock

1. The Type of Potato Matters Most

Potatoes generally fall into two groups: starchy and waxy. Starchy potatoes, like russets, break down easily when cooked and turn light and fluffy when mashed. Waxy potatoes, like small red potatoes, hold their shape and stay firmer, which is great for potato salad but not always for a smooth mash.

The russet is the classic choice for mashed potatoes because of its high starch content. It absorbs butter and milk beautifully and produces that cloud-like texture many people grew up with. If your family loves fluffy, airy mashed potatoes, russets are the way to go.

2. Yukon Golds Are the Creamy Favorite

Many cooks swear by Yukon Gold potatoes for mashing. They fall somewhere between starchy and waxy, so they mash smoothly while keeping a rich, creamy texture. Their golden flesh also has a naturally buttery flavor that makes them taste rich even before you add the butter.

Some families mix russets and Yukon Golds to get the best of both, with fluffiness from the russets and creaminess from the Yukons. If you’re not sure which your family prefers, buying some of each is an easy way to experiment. Red potatoes work well for chunky, skin-on “smashed” potatoes, but they can turn pasty if you try to whip them smooth.

3. Plan on About Half a Pound per Person

Running out of mashed potatoes on Thanksgiving is almost unthinkable in many households. A good rule of thumb is about half a pound of raw potatoes per person, which gives most guests a generous serving. If your family loves leftovers or has big eaters, plan on a little more.

That means a 5-pound bag will feed about 10 people, and a 10-pound bag will feed about 20. Since potatoes are among the most affordable foods in the produce section, many hosts round up rather than risk coming up short. Leftover mashed potatoes can be turned into potato pancakes, shepherd’s pie or a topping for casseroles.

4. Check the Bag Before You Buy

A bag of potatoes can hide a few problems. Before tossing one into your cart, take a quick look through the plastic or mesh. Avoid bags with potatoes that are soft, wrinkled, shriveled or sprouting, and skip any that have a lot of cuts, bruises or dark spots.

Watch for potatoes with a greenish tint on the skin, which happens when potatoes are exposed to light. Green areas can taste bitter and should be cut away before cooking, so it’s better to choose firm potatoes with no green at all. Many shoppers prefer buying loose potatoes so they can pick each one by hand.

5. Buy a Few Days Ahead, Then Store Them Right

Thanksgiving week is one of the busiest times of year at grocery stores, and the produce section can get picked over. Buying potatoes a few days early is a smart way to avoid the rush. Potatoes keep well, as long as they’re stored properly.

Keep them in a cool, dark, well-ventilated place, such as a pantry or cupboard, rather than on a sunny counter. Take them out of plastic bags if you can, and store them away from onions, which can make them sprout faster. Before the holiday, it’s also a good time for a few fridge and freezer checks so there’s room for everything else.

6. Don’t Forget What Goes With Them

The potatoes are only part of the dish. Before you leave the store, make sure you have plenty of butter, milk or cream, salt and any extras your family expects, like sour cream, cream cheese, garlic or chives. Running out of butter on Thanksgiving morning is a common and avoidable problem.

Gravy ingredients matter, too, since mashed potatoes and gravy are a famous pair. If you’re making gravy from the turkey drippings, you may still want flour or cornstarch and some extra broth. Some cooks also keep a jar of store-bought gravy on hand as a backup, just in case.

Consider Your Cooking Space

Before you buy 15 pounds of potatoes, think about how you’ll cook them. A large batch needs a big stockpot, plenty of room on the stove and time to peel and chop. On Thanksgiving, burners and oven space are precious, so plan where the potatoes fit into the day’s schedule.

Many hosts peel and cut their potatoes the morning of the holiday and keep them covered in cold water until it’s time to cook. Others make the mashed potatoes an hour or two ahead and keep them warm in a slow cooker, which frees up the stovetop for gravy and other last-minute dishes.

A Few Tips for Mashing Day

Once you’ve bought the right potatoes, a few simple steps help them turn out perfectly. Peel them if you like, cut them into evenly sized chunks and start them in cold, well-salted water so they cook evenly. Simmer them until a fork slides in easily, then drain them well.

Warm the butter and milk before adding them so the potatoes stay hot and absorb everything smoothly. A hand masher or ricer gives a fluffy result, while an electric mixer can make them gummy if you overdo it. Taste and season at the end, and keep them warm in a slow cooker if dinner gets delayed.

The Dish Everyone Waits For

Mashed potatoes may seem simple, but they’re one of the most loved dishes on the Thanksgiving table. Choosing the right potatoes and buying enough of them is the first step toward a bowl that disappears before the second helping of turkey.

Does your family prefer russets, Yukon Golds or red potatoes for mashing? And do you leave the skins on or peel them every time?

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *