7 Thanksgiving Side Dishes From the 1980s Families Rarely Make Anymore

The Thanksgiving table of the 1980s looked a lot like the one we set today, with turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes and pie. But look a little closer at the old family photos and you will spot a few side dishes that have nearly vanished: wobbly gelatin molds, green fluffy salads, a cut-glass relish tray and a bowl of creamed onions that only Grandpa seemed to eat.

These dishes were easy, inexpensive and made ahead, which is exactly why they ruled the 1980s holiday spread. Here are seven Thanksgiving sides from that era that families rarely make anymore, and what made each one special.

Holiday side dishes on a festive table
Image Credit: peopleimages12 via 123RF

1. The Molded Jell-O Salad

No 1980s Thanksgiving buffet felt complete without something shimmering in a ring mold. Fruit suspended in cherry or lime gelatin, sometimes with cottage cheese or whipped topping folded in, was a showpiece that could be made the day before. The only trick was unmolding it without a crack, and a stuck mold was one of those kitchen mistakes that make us cringe even now.

The tradition was already old by then. According to History.com, Jell-O was invented in 1897, gelatin salads took off in the 1920s and 1930s, and the 1950s were their golden age. History.com notes that savory gelatin salads largely fell out of favor in the 1970s, though the sweet fruit versions hung on at holiday tables for years. They belong right alongside the other foods Grandma always served at Thanksgiving that are vanishing from tables.

2. Watergate Salad

This pale green mix of pistachio pudding, crushed pineapple, mini marshmallows, chopped nuts and whipped topping was a potluck and holiday favorite. It was sweet enough to be dessert, but it usually sat on the table right next to the turkey.

The name is still a bit of a mystery. Mental Floss reports that Kraft says its “Pistachio Pineapple Delight” recipe was later renamed Watergate salad, but the company cannot confirm the popular story about why. Mental Floss also notes that “Watergate cake” recipes showed up in newspapers in 1973, before the salad borrowed the name.

3. Ambrosia

Ambrosia was the bright, sunny bowl on the table: canned mandarin oranges, pineapple, shredded coconut and mini marshmallows, often bound with sour cream or whipped topping. Some families added maraschino cherries for color, and some swore by pecans.

It still shows up in parts of the South, but in many homes it has quietly been replaced by a simple fruit platter. For anyone who grew up with it, a spoonful tastes like a 1980s holiday, one of those little rituals from the ’80s and ’90s that disappeared without much notice.

4. Waldorf Salad

Apples, celery, walnuts and mayonnaise do not sound like a holiday showstopper, but in the 1980s plenty of hosts set out a bowl of Waldorf salad, sometimes with raisins or grapes tossed in. It added crunch to a plate full of soft, rich food.

The dish has a fancy pedigree. CultureNOW credits Oscar Tschirky, the famous maitre d’ known as “Oscar of the Waldorf,” who included the salad in his 1896 cookbook. These days it is more likely to show up at a spring luncheon than at Thanksgiving, much like the creamy picks on the list of 1980s salad bar items that seem strange now.

Striped layered gelatin dessert in a cup
Image Credit: artcookstudio via 123RF

5. Creamed Pearl Onions

Small white onions simmered in a buttery white sauce, sometimes with a pinch of nutmeg or a crumb topping, were a fixture at many older family dinners. Peeling dozens of tiny onions was the job nobody wanted, which is probably why frozen versions in a box became so popular. The dish lives on in memories and in plenty of nostalgic things everyone had 30 years ago, but it rarely makes the cut on modern menus.

If you want to bring it back, a bag of frozen pearl onions takes most of the work out of it, and the sauce can be made the morning of the holiday. Just keep the heat low and stir often so the sauce stays smooth.

6. The Relish Tray

Before charcuterie boards, there was the relish tray. It was usually a divided glass dish loaded with black olives, sweet gherkins, pickled beets, radishes, carrot sticks and celery stuffed with cream cheese or pimento cheese. Kids put olives on their fingertips, and adults snacked on it while the turkey rested.

Many families have swapped it for a bigger appetizer spread, but the old-fashioned version still has fans. It needs no oven space, which every Thanksgiving host can appreciate.

7. Seven-Layer Salad

This one was built in a clear glass bowl so everyone could see the stripes: iceberg lettuce, peas, red onion, hard-boiled eggs, cheddar and bacon, all sealed under a thick layer of mayonnaise dressing and chilled overnight. It was a 1980s potluck star and showed up at plenty of holiday tables too.

It was made a day ahead and kept in the fridge until serving, which freed up the host on the big day. Today it is more common at summer cookouts, if it appears at all.

These sides may not be on many tables anymore, but they tell the story of how families cooked in the 1980s: thrifty, make-ahead and proudly colorful. If someone in your family still asks for the green fluffy salad or the relish tray, this might be the year to make it again.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *