8 Hot Drinks Americans Sipped on Winter Nights Before Pumpkin Spice
Long before coffee shops lined up a fall menu, Americans had plenty of ways to warm up on a cold winter night. A saucepan of milk on the stove, a jar of homemade tea mix or a punch bowl brought out only in December did the job just fine.
Pumpkin spice is actually a fairly recent arrival. Below are eight cozy drinks families sipped for decades before it showed up, and every one of them is still easy to make at home.

1. Instant Hot Cocoa From a Packet
For many kids, winter meant a paper packet, a mug of hot water and a little cloud of marshmallows. Military.com reports that Charles Sanna developed instant cocoa from a surplus of powdered creamer his family company made for troops during the Korean War, and that the mix was branded Swiss Miss in 1961. He first sold it to restaurants and airlines, then realized customers were taking the packets home.
Mugs of cocoa went hand in hand with snow days and the Saturday morning cartoon classics from the ’60s and ’70s.
2. Stovetop Hot Chocolate
Grandma’s version took a little longer. Cocoa powder, sugar and a pinch of salt were whisked into warm milk in a saucepan, sometimes with a splash of vanilla or a drop of peppermint. It was thicker and richer than anything from a packet, and it was the perfect finish to a supper of the comfort dishes boomer grandmothers still make every winter.
3. Hot Spiced Apple Cider
Simmer apple cider with cinnamon sticks, whole cloves and a few orange slices, and the whole house smells like the holidays. It was the drink of choice at church suppers, school carnivals and hayrides, often ladled out of a big electric percolator into paper cups.
4. Russian Tea
This one is a Southern favorite with a funny name. According to Garden & Gun, Russian tea is not actually from Russia. Americans started drinking black tea with lemon and sugar to imitate upper-class Russian habits, and Southern cooks later added clove and cinnamon. After World War II, the magazine says, Tang, powdered lemonade and instant tea became the base of the dry mix many people remember, often layered in a Mason jar as a holiday gift.
5. The Tom and Jerry
If you grew up in Wisconsin, Minnesota or nearby, you may remember a special punch bowl that only came out at Christmas. Atlas Obscura describes the Tom and Jerry as a Midwestern holiday staple made from a sweet, spiced egg batter thinned with hot milk or water and spiked with brandy or rum. The magazine notes that milk glass bowl and mug sets lettered with the drink’s name were common from the 1940s through the 1960s.

Those matching sets are now treasured flea market finds, right up there with the nostalgic items everyone had 30 years ago. Gathering around the punch bowl was one of those little rituals that disappeared without much notice, much like ordering at the counter in our list of soda fountain drinks your grandparents ordered.
6. Hot Buttered Rum
For grown-ups, a pat of butter mixed with brown sugar and warm spices, topped with hot water and a shot of rum, was a classic fireside drink. Many families kept a batch of the spiced butter mix in the fridge all season so a mug could be stirred up in seconds.
7. A Warm Mug of Malted Milk
Malted milk powder stirred into warm milk was a bedtime favorite in plenty of homes. Brands like Ovaltine were pantry regulars, and the toasty, slightly nutty flavor still tastes like childhood to many people.
8. Percolator Coffee After Supper
In many homes, the evening ended with a pot of coffee perking on the stove or the counter. The gurgling sound and the little glass bubble on top were part of the ritual. Coffee with a slice of pie was how company stayed a little longer on cold nights.
The pumpkin spice era began quietly. Starbucks says its Pumpkin Spice Latte was first tested in fall 2003 in about 100 stores in Vancouver and Washington, D.C. It is fun, but the old favorites are still waiting in the pantry. Pick one, put the kettle on and enjoy a winter night the old-fashioned way.
