10 Discontinued Kids’ Snacks From the 1990s Millennials Still Crave

The 1990s were a wild time to be a kid in the snack aisle. Everything was neon, everything had a cartoon mascot, and half the fun was squeezing, twisting or peeling your food before you ate it. If you packed lunches in that decade, or ate one, you probably remember the trading game at the cafeteria table.

Ask a millennial today about their favorite childhood snack and there is a good chance it no longer exists. Some of these treats lasted only a few years, and some made a brief comeback before vanishing again. Fans have started online petitions, written letters to food companies and even built websites begging for their return.

Here is a look at ten 1990s kids’ snacks that disappeared from store shelves, along with what happened to them. Parents who bought them by the case will remember a few of these too, maybe a little less fondly.

Children eating a snack at the kitchen table
Image Credit: t.tomsickova/Deposit Photos

1. Planters P.B. Crisps

Planters rolled out P.B. Crisps in 1992, and they came with a catchy TV jingle that stuck in kids’ heads for years. They were peanut-shaped crunchy shells with a creamy peanut butter center, and later flavors added chocolate and strawberry fillings to the mix.

They lasted only about three years. As Sporked notes, Planters has said there simply was not enough demand to keep making them, and the snack was gone by around 1995. Even so, P.B. Crisps remain one of the most requested discontinued snacks online, with a fan website and petitions still floating around.

2. Butterfinger BB’s

Butterfinger BB’s were tiny, round bites of the candy bar, sold in a pouch that fit perfectly in a backpack pocket. They arrived in 1992 and got a huge boost from TV ads starring Bart Simpson, which made them feel like the coolest candy in the store.

They hung around longer than most snacks on this list. Nestlé made them until 2006, according to a 24/7 Wall St. roundup. Later bite-size Butterfinger products came along, but fans insist the original BB’s had a texture all their own.

3. Cheetos Cheesy Checkers

Cheesy Checkers were a fun twist on regular Cheetos, shaped into little square grids that looked like a checkerboard. For kids who liked their snacks to look a little different from everyone else’s, they were a lunchbox prize.

Frito-Lay sold them from 1995 to 1998, which is a short run even by snack standards. Plenty of millennials still remember the bright orange dust they left on their fingers. Every so often, someone posts an old bag on social media and the comments fill up with people asking where they went.

4. Hi-C Ecto Cooler

No lunchbox drink was more 1990s than Ecto Cooler. Hi-C launched the green citrus drink as a tie-in with “The Real Ghostbusters” cartoon, and the box featured Slimer, the green ghost, which made it feel like you were drinking straight out of the movie.

The drink outlived the cartoon by years. Mental Floss reports that Slimer left the box and the drink was renamed Shoutin’ Orange Tangergreen around 2001, then Crazy Citrus Cooler, before it was finally dropped in 2007. Coca-Cola brought it back briefly for new Ghostbusters films in 2016 and 2021, and each time fans cleared the shelves fast.

5. Squeezit

Squeezits were the drinks you had to squeeze to sip, with colorful plastic bottles that kids squeezed like a toy. General Mills launched them in 1985, but they became a true lunchroom favorite in the 1990s, when twisting off the top was a small daily victory.

According to Tasting Table, slumping sales led General Mills to discontinue them in 2001. They popped back up for short stretches later on, but never for long. A fan petition to bring them back has gathered thousands of signatures, which tells you how many grown-ups still think about them.

6. Fruit String Thing

General Mills made a lot of fruit snacks in the 1990s, but Fruit String Thing stood out because it came as long, chewy strings that kids could tie into knots or wrap around a finger. It was part snack, part toy, and teachers probably did not love it.

The strings were gone by the early 2000s. Fruit snacks are still everywhere today, but the long, stretchy string format never made a real comeback. Millennials who grew up with them still talk about trying to eat one without breaking it.

7. Starburst Fruit Twists

Starburst Fruit Twists took the famous candy flavors and turned them into soft, twisted ropes. They were a chewy answer to licorice for kids who did not like licorice, and they were a common pick at the movie theater and the corner store.

They disappeared in the early 2000s, around the same time as many other twisty, chewy treats. Starburst itself is still going strong, of course, which makes the loss sting a little more. Fans say nothing else had that same soft, fruity pull.

8. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Pies

In 1991, Hostess cashed in on Turtle mania with a dessert pie that had a bright green crust and a “vanilla puddin'” filling. Each one came with trading cards or stickers, so kids were buying them as much for the collectibles as for the snack.

As Tasting Table recounts, the Turtle pies were a spin-off of Hostess pudding pies, which had been pulled a few years earlier. They did not last past 1991. The wrappers and cards are now collector’s items, and the pies even got a nod on a TV sitcom decades later.

9. Keebler Pizzarias

Keebler Pizzarias were pizza-flavored chips shaped like little pizza slices. They arrived in 1991 and were a hit at sleepovers, where a bag of them felt like a party food you could eat any night of the week.

Sources disagree on when they vanished, with some saying the mid-1990s and others closer to 2000. Either way, they were gone before most millennials finished school. Keebler’s move away from salty snacks and toward cookies is often blamed for their exit.

10. Reese’s Bites

Reese’s Bites were bite-size peanut butter and chocolate candies sold in a bag you could shake straight into your hand. They arrived from Hershey in 1999, just in time to close out the decade.

They lasted until about 2004, according to snack history roundups. Reese’s has released plenty of mini and bite-size products since then, but fans of the originals swear they were different. They are one more reminder that the snack aisle can change faster than kids grow up.

Why Millennials Still Miss These Snacks

Part of the reason these snacks stick in memory is that they were never just food. They came with mascots, trading cards, squeeze bottles and cartoons, and they were tied to Saturday mornings and lunch table swaps. Many of them show up on lists of childhood snacks that disappeared because they defined a very specific moment.

Millennials get blamed for “killing” plenty of things, from cereal to napkins, but some experts disagree with that idea. When it comes to snacks, this generation is doing the opposite and loudly asking for old favorites to come back. Food companies have listened before, too, with a few brands making short-term returns after fan campaigns.

Which of these did you have in your lunchbox? Did you squeeze, twist or trade your way through the 1990s? Tell us in the comments which snack you would bring back first, and whether you think it would taste as good today as you remember.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *