Why Fruitcake Became America’s Most Joked-About Christmas Food

Every December, fruitcake shows up in two places: on holiday tables and in holiday jokes. For every person who looks forward to a slice of dense, boozy, fruit-packed cake, there seem to be ten more ready to laugh about the brick-like loaf that gets passed from house to house and never actually eaten.

It’s hard to think of another food that has been mocked quite so much. Comedians have made fun of it for decades, towns have held contests to see how far people can throw it and many families joke about the same fruitcake getting regifted year after year. And yet, fruitcake has survived for centuries.

So how did this old-fashioned holiday cake become the punch line of Christmas? The answer involves history, mail-order bakeries, a famous late-night joke and a cake that was built to last. Here’s the story.

Why Fruitcake Became America's Most Joked-About Christmas Food
Image Credit: Nadianb/Deposit Photos

A Very Old Cake

Fruitcake has been around for a very long time. Cakes made with dried fruit, nuts and honey go back to ancient times, and fruit-filled breads and cakes became popular in Europe during the Middle Ages. As sugar became more available, bakers used it to preserve fruit, which made rich fruitcakes possible.

According to Wikipedia’s history of fruitcake, the cake became closely linked with celebrations like weddings and Christmas in Britain. Fruit and spices were expensive, so a fruitcake was a sign of a special occasion. British settlers brought the tradition to America, where it became a Christmas staple.

Built to Last

One of fruitcake’s defining features is that it keeps for a very long time. The candied fruit is preserved in sugar, and many recipes call for brushing or soaking the cake in brandy, rum or whiskey. That combination helps the cake stay moist and safe to eat for weeks or even months.

That long shelf life was a big advantage in the days before refrigeration. Families could bake fruitcakes well before Christmas and let them “age” in a tin, sometimes feeding them with more liquor every week. But it also became the root of many jokes. A cake that lasts so long seemed almost indestructible.

The Mail-Order Fruitcake Boom

In the 20th century, fruitcake became one of America’s most popular mail-order gifts. The Collin Street Bakery in Corsicana, Texas, founded in 1896, became famous for shipping its DeLuxe fruitcakes all over the world. In Georgia, the Claxton Bakery turned the small town of Claxton into the self-proclaimed “Fruitcake Capital of the World.”

Businesses ordered fruitcakes by the thousands to send to clients and employees. Families mailed them to relatives in other states. Because they kept so well, fruitcakes were perfect for shipping. Civic groups got in on it too, selling fruitcakes door to door as a holiday fundraiser for decades, so many households ended up with more than one. That also meant many people received fruitcakes they hadn’t asked for, which helped fuel the regifting jokes. If you’re mailing one this year, check the holiday shipping dates early.

The Famous Johnny Carson Joke

Many people trace fruitcake’s reputation as a joke to Johnny Carson. The longtime host of “The Tonight Show” famously quipped that there is only one fruitcake in the world, and people keep sending it to each other. The line became one of the most repeated fruitcake jokes ever.

Carson made fun of fruitcake on several occasions, and his huge audience helped spread the idea that fruitcake was something people gave away rather than ate. Over the years, comedians, cartoonists and TV writers kept the joke going. It became a holiday tradition all its own.

Neon Fruit and Heavy Loaves

Another reason fruitcake gets mocked is its appearance. Many mass-produced fruitcakes are filled with candied cherries and citron dyed bright red and green. To some people, the neon fruit looks artificial and unappealing, nothing like the fresh fruit they enjoy the rest of the year.

Fruitcakes are also famously heavy. A small loaf can weigh a surprising amount, thanks to all that fruit and nuts packed into a little batter. Slicing one cleanly takes a sharp knife and a steady hand, and a thick slice can feel like a full meal. That heft has inspired endless jokes about using fruitcake as a doorstop, a paperweight or even a building material.

The Great Fruitcake Toss

The jokes eventually turned into an actual event. In Manitou Springs, Colorado, people gather each year for the Great Fruitcake Toss, where participants launch fruitcakes as far as they can. Some throw them by hand, while others build catapults and other contraptions.

The event started in the 1990s and has become a fun local tradition, attracting visitors and media attention. Organizers have even encouraged people to bring their unwanted holiday fruitcakes to toss. It’s the perfect example of how fruitcake has become as much a source of fun as a dessert.

People Who Truly Love It

For all the jokes, fruitcake still has loyal fans. Many people say a good homemade fruitcake, made with quality dried fruit, nuts and spices, is nothing like the cheap versions that gave the cake its bad reputation. For them, it’s a rich, flavorful treat that tastes like Christmas.

Fruitcake is also tied to family memories. Many people remember their grandmothers baking fruitcakes in the fall, wrapping them in cheesecloth soaked in brandy and storing them until Christmas. A slice of fruitcake can bring those memories rushing back. It’s one of the Christmas foods boomers loved that younger generations rarely see.

Is Fruitcake Making a Comeback?

In recent years, some bakers have tried to give fruitcake a fresh image. They use high-quality dried fruits like apricots, figs and cherries instead of dyed candied fruit. Some make lighter versions with less batter and more flavor. Artisan bakeries sell fruitcakes that win over even longtime skeptics.

Still, the jokes aren’t going anywhere. Fruitcake’s place in American humor is as secure as its place in holiday history. Whether you love it or laugh at it, it remains one of the most memorable foods of the season. It’s one of many holiday traditions that puzzle the rest of the world.

Are you a fruitcake fan, or do you think it deserves the jokes? And has a fruitcake ever been regifted in your family?

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *