Name: Easy Easter Jello Pie Jars Recipe
Prep time: 10 min
Cook time: 360 min
Total time: 360 min
Ingredients: 1/2 package (3 ounce strawberry gelatin); 1/2 package (3 ounce grape gelatin); 1/2 package (3 ounce lemon gelatin); 1/2 package (3 ounce berry blue gelatin); 3 cups boiling water; 1 1/3 cups cold water; 16 ounces cool whip; Whipped cream; Sprinkles; Bunny Peeps

This post may contain affiliate links.

Jump to Recipe Jump to Video Print Recipe

Fun, yummy, and easy-to-make Easter Jello Pie Jars desserts are a perfect way to celebrate any occasion. These individual jars are perfect for kids and adults alike, and they’re so easy to make!

Pastel Rainbow Easter Jello Pie Jars

Easter is just around the corner, and what better way to celebrate than with some fun and festive jello pie jars?

These are a little different than the Easter Jello Rainbow Pie Dessert as this doesn’t have yogurt in it like the other one.

However, they both taste awesome!

These individual jars are perfect for kids and adults alike, and they’re so easy to make!

Plus, they can be easily customized the colors to your liking.

You won’t be able to stop eating this delicious 4-layer Easter Jello jars recipe!

The colorful layers of jello and whipped cream make it perfect for any celebration, but we especially like how you can enjoy such an impressive dish at celebrations with friends or family.

Fun, yummy, and easy-to-make desserts are a perfect way to celebrate any occasion.

I love the fact that you can get creative with your Jello pie by using different colors of gelatins which gives it an extra special touch!

My family loves these tasty treats at easter time because they’re not only sweet but also have some fun flavor combinations going on in them too.

Read on for the recipe!

Makes 5 jars

Prep time: 10 minutes

Chill time: 6 hours

What You Need to Make this Easter Pie Recipe

Strawberry gelatin
Grape gelatin
Lemon gelatin
Berry blue gelatin
Water
Cold water
Cool whip
Whipped cream
Sprinkles
Bunny Peeps

Supplies Needed to Make Rainbow Jello Pie Jars

Wide Mouth Mason Jars – Wide mouth jars are better, however, you can use any jar you would like.
Piping bag – And once again, while disposable bags are not a necessity, they are so less messy because you don’t have to clean them. But, if you have regular piping bags, go right ahead and use them. You can also just use a plain plastic baggie with the corner snipped off if that’s all you have too.
Rubber spatula
Microwave safe bowls
Dessert plates (I like disposable, lol)
Dessert forks (I don’t recommend disposable forks because the Easter Jello Pie is frozen and they will break.)
Easter table runner – to make your table look pretty and to set your Easter jello recipe on

What Size Jar Do I Need for the Easter Jello Pie Recipe

Recipes in a jar are all the rage right now. It’s easy to see why–they are adorable, convenient, and perfect for portion control!

The best thing is that you can make them in any size jars that you’d like.

Whether you choose mason jars or dessert glasses, they are readily available at Walmart or Amazon in many different sizes.

I chose the pint-size (16 ounces) for this recipe.

Holiday Jell-O Pudding Pie Variations

Depending on what holiday you want to make the Jello Pudding Pie Jars for, just switch up the colors of the jello used.

4th of July – Red, White, and Blue made with Strawberry, and blue raspberry jello topped with whipped cream.
St. Patrick’s Day – Green jello and whipped cream or rainbow colors are also a nice touch for St. Patrick’s Day.
Christmas – Red jello, and green jello topped with whipped cream.

There are so many different variations that there are too many to list. Use your imagination and you will have a one-of-a-kind dessert that tastes great.

More Easter Recipes

Cinnamon Sugar Crescent Roll Bunnies – These cinnamon sugar crescent roll bunnies are too cute to resist! They’re perfect for Easter brunch or an afternoon snack. And they’re so easy to make!
Peeps Pudding Cups Recipe – Made from layers of Oreo cookies and pudding, topped with mini chocolate eggs, these Easter cups are perfect for any bunny who likes their treats on the sweet side.
Perfect 4 Layer Easter Jello Recipe – Looking for a fun and festive Easter recipe? 4 layer Easter Jello recipe with layers of colorful jello and whipped cream, it’s perfect for any Easter celebration.
Easy Cake Mix Cookie Bars – Made with just a few simple ingredients, these Easter Cake Mix Cookie Bars come together quickly and taste delicious. Keep reading for the recipe.
Osterbrot: German Easter Bread Recipe – The Osterbrot: German Easter Bread Recipe is also known as Hefezopf. A sweet European bread made from eggs right in your kitchen.

How to Make Easter Jello Pie Jars

Pour each flavor of gelatin into a separate bowl.

To each bowl, add 2/3 cup boiling water.

Stir until the gelatin is completely dissolved, then add 1/3 cup cold water.

Stir to mix, then place the bowl in the refrigerator to chill for 20 to 30 minutes, until the mixture is just beginning to thicken.

Add one cup of Cool Whip to each bowl and stir to mix. Return the bowl to the refrigerator for 1 to 1 ½ hours, until the mixture has thickened.

Transfer each flavor to a separate piping bag and pipe each color in layers into the jars.

Put the lids on the jars and place them in the refrigerator to chill for at least 4 hours.

When ready to serve, remove the lids and top each jar with whipped cream.

Decorate with sprinkles and one bunny Peep.

Make sure to give yourself enough time for the jello to set before serving.

Can I Make This With Sugar Free Jello

I have not tried it with sugar-free jello, but there’s a first time for everything.

Sugar-free jello doesn’t have the consistency as regular jello, however, I have used sugar-free when making jello shots and I did not notice a difference one way or another.

Can I Bake a No Bake Jell-O Pie

No-Bake jello pie jars recipe is one of the best ways to enjoy your favorite jello pie without all the work.

I don’t know why anyone would want to bake a no-bake Jell-O pudding pie. However, hence the name no-bake…there’s no need to bake.

Printable Recipe Card