9 Northern Dishes Southerners Just Don’t Get
Southerners are proud of their food, and for good reason. Biscuits, fried chicken, grits, collard greens and sweet tea are part of a cooking tradition that’s loved across the country. So when Southerners travel north and sit down to a Northern meal, some of what lands on the table can leave them scratching their heads.
The North has its own deeply loved food traditions, shaped by immigrants, cold winters and regional pride. To a New Englander or a Midwesterner, these dishes are comfort food. To many Southerners, they’re a mystery, or at least a reason for some friendly teasing.
The good-natured North-versus-South food debate has been going on for generations, and it isn’t ending anytime soon. Here are nine Northern dishes that many Southerners just don’t get.

1. Unsweetened Iced Tea
Let’s start with the drink. In much of the North, if you order iced tea at a restaurant, it arrives unsweetened, with sugar packets on the side. Southerners are often stunned. Stirring sugar into cold tea never dissolves properly, and to them, tea without sugar already in it isn’t really tea.
In the South, sweet tea is practically a way of life, brewed strong and mixed with sugar while still hot. Northerners who visit the South often find it far too sweet. This one small difference has started more friendly arguments than almost any dish on the menu.
2. New England Boiled Dinner
A New England boiled dinner is corned beef or ham simmered in a big pot with cabbage, potatoes, carrots and turnips. It’s hearty and filling, and many New England families have served it for generations, especially in winter and on St. Patrick’s Day.
Southerners, who often season vegetables with smoked meat, spices and plenty of salt, sometimes find boiled dinner bland. Boiling everything together in plain water just doesn’t match the bold flavors many Southern cooks grew up with.
3. Cincinnati Chili
Cincinnati chili is spiced with cinnamon, cloves and sometimes chocolate, then served over spaghetti and piled with shredded cheddar. Locals order it “three-way,” “four-way” or “five-way,” depending on the toppings.
For Southerners, and especially Texans, this is a shock. Chili, to them, is a thick bowl of beef and chiles, never poured over noodles. Many Southern visitors to Ohio say Cincinnati chili is good, but they refuse to call it chili.
4. Scrapple
In Pennsylvania, Delaware and Maryland, scrapple is a breakfast favorite. It’s made from pork scraps, cornmeal and spices, formed into a loaf, then sliced and fried until crispy. Locals love it with eggs, ketchup or apple butter.
Southerners have plenty of their own pork traditions, from country ham to souse, but scrapple’s mysterious ingredient list makes many of them hesitate. Once they try it, though, some admit it’s not so different from the frugal dishes their own grandparents ate.
5. Hotdish
In Minnesota and parts of the upper Midwest, a hotdish is a casserole usually made with ground beef, canned soup, vegetables and a crispy topping of tater tots. It’s a staple at church suppers, potlucks and family gatherings.
Southerners love casseroles too, but the word “hotdish” confuses them, and the tater tot topping can seem unusual. Many point out that the South has its own legendary casseroles, from squash casserole to sweet potato casserole topped with marshmallows.
6. Clam Chowder With No Cornbread in Sight
New England clam chowder is a creamy soup full of clams and potatoes, usually served with oyster crackers. In Boston and along the coast, it’s practically sacred.
Southerners don’t dislike chowder, but they’re puzzled by the oyster crackers. In the South, soups and stews come with a piece of cornbread or a biscuit, not tiny crackers. Some Southern visitors also find the North’s thick, creamy soups heavy compared with the brothy stews they know.
7. Pierogi
In Pittsburgh, Cleveland, Buffalo and Chicago, pierogi are everywhere. These Eastern European dumplings, filled with potato, cheese or sauerkraut and fried with butter and onions, are a beloved part of the Rust Belt’s immigrant heritage.
Many Southerners didn’t grow up with them and aren’t sure what to make of them at first. But since the South has its own love of dumplings, especially chicken and dumplings, most come around quickly once they taste a good plate of pierogi.
8. Lobster Rolls at Lobster Prices
A Maine lobster roll is a simple sandwich of fresh lobster meat in a buttered, toasted bun. In New England, it’s a summer must-have, and people happily pay a premium for it.
Southerners, who have their own seafood traditions, often balk at the price. A shrimp po’ boy in New Orleans costs a fraction of what a lobster roll does in Maine. To many Southern visitors, paying $30 or more for a sandwich is hard to understand, even if they love the taste.
9. Grits Served With Sugar, or Not at All
Northerners who do eat grits sometimes serve them like oatmeal, with sugar and milk. Many Northern diners don’t serve grits at all, offering hash browns or home fries instead.
To Southerners, grits are savory, served with butter, salt, cheese or shrimp. Putting sugar on grits is one of the few food crimes that can truly upset a Southerner. It’s a debate that comes up whenever North and South sit down to breakfast together. Some of the strangest regional food quirks show up in lists of unusual delicacies across the U.S., and plenty of them come from the North.
Why the Debate Never Ends
Regional food loyalties run deep because they’re tied to family. The dish someone grew up eating at Grandma’s table is the dish that tastes like home, no matter where they live now. That’s why so many transplants from the North or South go looking for their hometown favorites after they move.
A Debate That Brings People Together
The North-South food debate is mostly in good fun. Regional dishes reflect the people who settled each area, the crops they grew and the climate they lived in. New England’s boiled dinners came from Irish and English settlers, the Rust Belt’s pierogi from Eastern European workers and the upper Midwest’s hotdish from church potluck culture.
At the end of the day, both sides love comfort food. They just disagree about what that means. And as many families who’ve married across the Mason-Dixon line can tell you, there’s room on any holiday table for sweet tea and unsweet, grits and hash browns, cornbread and oyster crackers. The Southern dishes Northerners don’t get could fill a whole other list, and the debate will go on for generations.
