8 Foods That Were a Big Deal to Order at a 1960s Restaurant

In the 1960s, eating out was not something most families did every week. For many, a restaurant dinner was saved for birthdays, anniversaries, graduations or the occasional Sunday after church. When families did go out, they dressed up, minded their manners and often ordered something they would never make at home.

Some menu items carried a special sense of occasion. Ordering them felt fancy, grown up or even a little daring. Many boomers still remember watching their parents order these dishes, or the thrill of being allowed to order one themselves. Here are eight foods that were a big deal to order at a 1960s restaurant.

Raw lobster on ice on a black stone table top view
Image Credit: Shutterstock

1. Shrimp Cocktail

Shrimp cocktail was the height of elegance in the 1960s. Chilled shrimp hung over the rim of a glass, served with a tangy cocktail sauce and a wedge of lemon. Ordering it as an appetizer signaled that this was a special night out.

Shrimp was expensive and not commonly cooked at home in many parts of the country. For families who rarely ate seafood, shrimp cocktail felt luxurious. Many boomers remember it as the first fancy food they ever tried.

2. Prime Rib

Prime rib was a showstopper at steakhouses and supper clubs. A thick, juicy slice of roast beef, served with au jus and horseradish, was a meal many families saved for big celebrations. Some restaurants carved it tableside from a rolling cart, adding to the drama.

Ordering prime rib was a sign of a big occasion, like an anniversary or a promotion. It was one of the most expensive items on the menu. Many people still consider it a special-occasion meal today.

3. Lobster

Lobster was a true luxury in the 1960s, especially outside of New England. Many restaurants listed it at “market price,” which made ordering it feel like a gamble. Diners wore plastic bibs and used nutcrackers to get at the meat.

For many families, ordering lobster was a once-in-a-lifetime experience. Some boomers remember their parents splitting a lobster on a special anniversary. Others recall trying it for the first time on a vacation to the coast.

4. Steak Diane or Steak au Poivre

Fancy steak dishes like Steak Diane and Steak au Poivre were popular in upscale 1960s restaurants. Steak Diane was often prepared tableside, flambéed in a pan with brandy for dramatic effect. Steak au Poivre was coated in cracked peppercorns and served with a rich cream sauce.

These dishes felt sophisticated and continental. Ordering one showed a diner’s taste for fine dining. Many people remember the flames leaping up from the pan as the waiter prepared the dish.

5. Baked Alaska

Baked Alaska was one of the most impressive desserts of the era. It featured ice cream on a layer of cake, covered in meringue and quickly browned or flambéed. The idea of hot meringue surrounding cold ice cream amazed diners.

Ordering Baked Alaska was often reserved for celebrations. Some restaurants set it on fire at the table, drawing gasps from nearby diners. It was a dessert that turned a meal into an event.

6. Chicken Kiev

Chicken Kiev, a chicken breast stuffed with herbed butter, breaded and fried, was a popular restaurant dish in the 1960s. When cut open, the butter spilled out, which was part of the fun. It felt elegant and continental compared to ordinary fried chicken.

Many home cooks later tried to make it, with mixed results. But in the 1960s, ordering Chicken Kiev at a restaurant was a special treat. It’s a dish that many boomers remember fondly.

7. Caesar Salad Made Tableside

In upscale 1960s restaurants, Caesar salad was often prepared tableside by a waiter. The waiter would mix the dressing in a large wooden bowl, adding garlic, anchovies, egg, lemon and Parmesan before tossing the romaine. Watching it being made was part of the experience.

For many diners, the Caesar salad was their first taste of anchovies and fresh Parmesan. It felt worldly and sophisticated. Today, Caesar salad is common, but the tableside show is rare.

8. A Kiddie Cocktail or Shirley Temple

For kids, the big deal at a 1960s restaurant was often a Shirley Temple or kiddie cocktail. Made with ginger ale or lemon-lime soda, grenadine and a maraschino cherry, it made children feel grown up. Some came with a little paper umbrella.

Many boomers remember sipping a Shirley Temple while their parents enjoyed cocktails. It made them feel included in the special evening. Some still order one today just for the nostalgia.

Why Eating Out Felt So Special

In the 1960s, eating out was a bigger event than it is today. Families generally ate most meals at home, and restaurant meals were a treat. Many people dressed up in their best clothes, and children were expected to behave.

Restaurants also offered dishes that were hard to make at home. Expensive ingredients, special techniques and dramatic presentations made the experience memorable. Families who rarely ate out often saved money for weeks to afford a nice dinner.

The Rise of Supper Clubs and Steakhouses

Supper clubs and steakhouses were especially popular in the Midwest and other regions during this era. These restaurants offered relish trays, cocktails, prime rib and live music. A night at the supper club was a highlight for many couples.

Some supper clubs are still open today, especially in Wisconsin, keeping the old traditions alive. Visiting one can feel like stepping back in time. Lists of diner classics show how some old favorites never really left the menu.

Dressing Up Was Part of the Meal

In the 1960s, going out to a nice restaurant meant putting on your best clothes. Men wore jackets and ties, women wore dresses, gloves and sometimes hats, and children were scrubbed and dressed in their Sunday outfits. Some upscale restaurants even kept spare jackets on hand for men who arrived without one.

Many boomers remember the excitement of getting ready for those evenings. The dressing up made the special dishes feel even more special, and children knew they were expected to sit up straight and use their best manners. For many families, the outfit and the ritual were as memorable as the food itself.

How Dining Out Has Changed

Today, eating out is far more common. Families dine at restaurants several times a week, and fast food and takeout are everyday options. Many once-fancy dishes, like shrimp cocktail and Caesar salad, are now widely available.

Still, many boomers miss the sense of occasion that came with eating out in the 1960s. They remember dressing up, ordering something special and feeling like the evening was an event. For them, those meals were about more than food. They were about celebrating with family and creating memories that lasted a lifetime.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *