A Greensboro Pub Adds a 20% Tip on Your Third Visit if You Skipped Tipping the First Two Times
A small sign inside a North Carolina pub has turned into one of the internet’s latest tipping debates. Freeman’s Grub & Pub in Greensboro has a policy that tracks customers who don’t tip, and if they skip it twice, the restaurant adds a 20 percent gratuity to their bill on the third visit. Photos of the sign spread online, and people have strong opinions about it.
Some critics say it’s an attempt to force customers to tip, which they believe should always be optional. Supporters, including some of the pub’s regulars, say it’s a fair way to make sure servers get paid for their work. Here’s how the policy works, why the owners say they started it and how customers are reacting.

How the Policy Works
According to WFMY News 2, the policy is simple. If a customer doesn’t leave a tip on two separate visits, the restaurant keeps those receipts on hand. When that customer comes back a third time, a 20 percent gratuity is automatically added to the bill.
The owners stress that it doesn’t apply to everyone who walks in the door. Most customers will never see an automatic charge because they already tip. The rule is aimed only at people who have repeatedly left nothing.
Why the Owners Started It
Emily and Kevin Purcell, who own the pub, told the station that the idea actually came from their employees. Staff members noticed that some regular customers weren’t tipping well or weren’t tipping at all. One employee suggested an automatic gratuity policy as a way to make sure servers were fairly paid.
Emily Purcell said the policy is about protecting the people who work for them. She told the station that just because restaurant workers don’t have a typical nine-to-five job doesn’t mean they don’t deserve to be paid. The owners decided to put up a sign so customers would know about the rule in advance.
The Sign Was Up for Months Before Going Viral
What surprised the owners most is that the sign wasn’t new. Emily Purcell said it had been posted inside the restaurant for months before it suddenly caught attention online. Once photos began circulating on social media, the pub found itself at the center of a national debate.
The attention brought a wave of negative reviews, many from people who had never visited. Purcell said those reviews didn’t bother her much because the people writing them had never set foot in the business. She said the pub cares more about the customers who show up and support its employees.
Tips Have Gone Up Since
The owners say the attention has had one clear effect. One longtime employee, who has been with the pub since the beginning, told them that tips have been higher since the policy went viral. He laughed about it, according to Purcell.
That suggests at least some customers who weren’t tipping before have changed their habits. Whether that’s because of the policy or the publicity is hard to say. Either way, the staff seems to be benefiting.
Regulars Back the Policy
Not everyone is upset about the sign. WFMY spoke with two regular customers, Mia Alsup and Sherry Mimis, who said they hadn’t noticed the sign before it went viral. Both said they support the restaurant’s effort to make sure employees get tipped.
Alsup said she was always in favor of tipping and is even more supportive now. Mimis said it’s unfortunately common for people to come in, get good service and then leave servers with nothing. For those customers, the policy simply puts a long-standing problem out in the open.
Why Tips Matter So Much to Servers
In many states, restaurants can pay servers a lower base wage because tips are expected to make up the difference. Under federal law, the minimum cash wage for tipped workers can be as low as $2.13 an hour, as long as tips bring their total pay up to the regular minimum wage. The U.S. Department of Labor lists each state’s rules on its tipped wage page.
North Carolina follows that federal tipped minimum. That means a customer who doesn’t tip is often leaving a server with very little for their time. Many servers say regular non-tippers can make a real dent in their weekly income.
Critics Say Tipping Should Stay Optional
Critics of the policy argue that a tip is supposed to be a reward for good service, not a required fee. Some worry that tracking customers’ receipts feels invasive. Others say restaurants should simply raise menu prices or pay workers more instead of adding charges.
This debate is part of a much bigger conversation about tipping in America. Many people feel they’re being asked to tip in more places than ever, and automatic charges have sparked plenty of disputes, like the woman who said a restaurant added an unexpected 18% tip to her family’s bill. Customers increasingly want to know exactly what they’re paying for before they order.
Automatic Gratuities Aren’t New
Restaurants have used automatic gratuities for years, most often for large parties. Many menus note that groups of six or eight or more will see a set tip added to the bill. Diners are usually expected to be told about it in advance, either on the menu or by the server.
What makes the Greensboro pub’s policy different is that it targets individual repeat customers based on their past behavior. That personal approach is what caught people’s attention online. Some see it as creative and fair, while others feel it crosses a line.
Restaurant owners across the country are watching how customers respond to policies like this one. As labor costs rise, more businesses are experimenting with service charges, higher menu prices and new ways to make sure workers are paid. The debate is likely to continue for some time.
Where Greensboro Diners Stand
For the Purcells, the decision comes down to valuing their employees. Emily Purcell told the station that they appreciate both their longtime regulars and the new customers discovering the pub. But she made it clear that supporting the staff is a priority.
If you’re a diner who always tips, this policy will never affect you. If you’re someone who skips the tip, you’ll want to know the rules before heading to Freeman’s. Either way, a small sign in a Greensboro pub has gotten a lot of people talking about what servers deserve.
