Holiday Spending Split: Lower-Income Americans Are Pulling Back While Everyone Else Plans to Spend More

Holiday spending plans are rising on average, but the headline number hides a much more divided picture.

The Conference Board estimates that consumers plan to spend $1,049 on gifts and other seasonal purchases this year, up 5.9% from $990 in 2025. Planned gift spending increased from $650 to $683, while spending on non-gift items such as food, decorations, and wrapping paper rose from $340 to $366.

But that does not mean most Americans are planning to spend more.

The biggest increase is concentrated among households earning $200,000 or more. Several other income groups are planning to reduce their gift budgets, creating a sharper divide beneath the overall increase.

Higher-income households are driving the increase

235403527 l
Image Credit: sinenkiy Via 123rf

Households earning $200,000 or more planned to increase their average gift spending by 13.6%.

That increase was large enough to lift the average gift budget for households earning $125,000 or more from $1,248 to $1,293, a 3.6% increase.

But looking only at that broader high-income group misses what is happening inside it.

Households earning between $125,000 and $149,999 planned to cut their average gift budgets by 9.4%. Those earning between $150,000 and $199,999 planned a 3.9% reduction.

Every broad household-income group below $125,000 also planned lower average gift spending.

So the story is not simply that lower-income households are cutting back while everyone else is spending more. The increase is heavily concentrated among the highest earners, while several other groups are pulling back.

Most gift shoppers are holding steady or cutting back

Another important detail sits behind the rising average.

Among people who planned to buy gifts, 50% expected to spend about the same amount as last year. Another 26% planned to spend less, while just 24% expected to spend more.

In other words, more gift buyers planned to reduce their spending than increase it.

That makes the higher average easier to understand. A relatively large increase among the highest earners can push the overall average upward even when many other households are maintaining or reducing their budgets.

The Conference Board survey included 3,000 U.S. respondents in October 2026.

Shoppers are looking for ways to stretch the budget

Consumers are also planning several strategies to keep holiday costs under control.

The most common approach was buying more items on sale, reported by 38% of respondents. Another 29% planned to spend less per person, while 29% planned to buy fewer gifts.

Rewards points or loyalty credits were another option, with 28% planning to use them. About 27% planned to start shopping earlier to spread purchases over time, while 20% expected to switch to cheaper brands or products.

These percentages are based on all survey respondents, and people could select more than one strategy.

That means the figures do not specifically describe lower-income households. They show the broader range of ways consumers expect to manage holiday costs.

The increase looks smaller after inflation

The spending increase also changes when inflation is considered.

The Conference Board’s combined estimate increased 3.2% from 2025 after adjusting for inflation. Real gift budgets increased 2.3%, while real spending plans for non-gift purchases rose 5%.

Even with those increases, the combined inflation-adjusted estimate remained 6.4% below its 2024 level.

So consumers are planning to spend more than they did last year, but the increase does not represent a complete return to the purchasing level recorded two years earlier.

Credit cards are part of the holiday plan

Payment methods also vary.

The survey found that 58% of respondents expected to use cash or debit cards. Another 31% planned to use credit cards they expected to pay in full, while 20% planned to use credit cards they expected to repay over time.

About 13% planned to use buy now, pay later or other installment payments.

Those figures can overlap because respondents were allowed to select multiple payment methods.

Installment payments were more common among younger respondents. About 21% of people under 35 planned to use them, compared with 17% of those ages 35 to 54 and 7% of those 55 and older.

The survey does not establish credit use by household income.

Another survey finds most people are keeping gift budgets steady

Gallup’s October survey offers another view of holiday spending plans.

It found that 54% of Americans expected to spend about the same on gifts, while 24% planned to spend less and 18% planned to spend more. Gallup’s average planned gift budget was $1,011, almost unchanged from $1,007 in October 2025.

That figure should not be directly compared with the Conference Board’s $683 gift estimate as though they measured exactly the same thing.

The Conference Board calculated its gift average among respondents planning to purchase gifts, while Gallup included zero-dollar responses. The surveys also used different samples and questions.

Still, both surveys point to a large share of consumers keeping their holiday gift spending steady rather than increasing it.

The bigger holiday picture is more complicated than one average

The Conference Board’s numbers show why an overall spending increase can be misleading if it is viewed without the income breakdown.

The average holiday budget is higher, but the increase is not spread evenly across households. The strongest gift-spending growth comes from households earning $200,000 or more, while every broad income group below $125,000 planned lower gift budgets. Even two groups above that level planned cuts.

For shoppers, the practical takeaway is that holiday spending remains a balancing act. Many consumers are planning sales shopping, smaller gift budgets, fewer purchases, or cheaper products, while others are preparing to spend more.

And these figures describe intentions, not completed holiday sales. What households ultimately spend will not be known from these plans alone.

For now, the clearest picture is a holiday season where the average is moving up, but the experience behind that average depends heavily on household income.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *