Newport Creamery Is Closing Two Longtime Restaurants, and Longtime Regulars Are Heartbroken
For generations of families in Rhode Island and southeastern Massachusetts, Newport Creamery has been more than a place to eat. It’s where kids celebrated birthdays, teenagers grabbed a frozen drink after school and families met for lunch on Saturdays. So the news that two of its longtime restaurants are closing has hit many customers hard.
The company announced it will close its locations on Smith Street in Providence and President Avenue in Fall River. Regulars say the restaurants are tied to decades of family memories. Here’s what the company said, what longtime customers are saying and what comes next for the beloved New England chain.

Two Locations Are Closing
According to NBC 10 News, Newport Creamery plans to close its restaurants on Smith Street in Providence and President Avenue in Fall River. The company’s announcement said both would close at the end of the year. However, employees at the Providence location told the station they believe their restaurant will close as soon as next week.
The station asked the company about the conflicting timelines but had not received a response as of Thursday night. Customers who want one last visit may want to go sooner rather than later. The exact closing dates may become clearer in the coming days.
Why the Company Says It’s Closing Them
Waterside Group bought Newport Creamery in March. Its CEO, Mark Bogosian, said the size and age of the buildings were the main reasons for the closures. He said the locations can’t accommodate the features the new owners want to bring to the restaurants.
Employees at the Providence restaurant also told NBC 10 that they believe roofing problems played a role in the decision there. They said some workers will transfer to other Newport Creamery locations, while others will not. For many staff members, the closures mean an uncertain few weeks ahead.
Regulars Share Their Memories
For longtime customers, the news was a shock. Lorraine Bertrand told the station that she and her cousins have met at the Fall River restaurant once a month for at least a decade. She said she was very sorry to hear it was closing.
Bertrand said the cousins will need to find another meeting place, but they don’t plan to give up their tradition. They intend to keep seeing each other at least once a month. For families like hers, the restaurant has been a gathering spot that helped hold relationships together.
“Terribly Sad. Astounded.”
At the Providence location, Joseph Fargnoli told NBC 10 that the announcement caught him completely off guard. He described himself as terribly sad and astounded, saying he didn’t expect it. Fargnoli grew up visiting the Smith Street restaurant before moving to Kentucky.
He said Newport Creamery is still the first place he goes whenever he comes back to Rhode Island. His order is always a coffee Awful Awful, the chain’s famous frozen drink. With the restaurant closing, he said he’ll probably save the cup as a souvenir.
The Famous Awful Awful
For anyone outside New England, the Awful Awful might need some explanation. It’s Newport Creamery’s signature thick frozen drink, similar to a milkshake, and it’s been a local favorite for generations. Its old slogan promised it was “awful big” and “awful good.”
Coffee is a particularly popular flavor in Rhode Island, which has a long love affair with coffee-flavored drinks, including coffee milk, the official state drink. Ordering a coffee Awful Awful is a rite of passage for many Rhode Island kids. Losing a favorite place to order one feels personal to many longtime fans.
Six Locations Will Remain
After the two closures, Newport Creamery will still have six locations across Rhode Island and Massachusetts. Fans who live near those restaurants can still order their favorite meals and drinks. The company also says it isn’t done growing.
A company spokesperson said design and construction have begun on several new locations planned for 2027. The company said it will announce those locations in the coming months but hasn’t said where they will be. For loyal fans, that offers some hope that the brand will continue for years to come.
Why Old Restaurants Close
Many longtime restaurants face similar challenges as their buildings age. Older structures can need costly repairs, like new roofs, updated kitchens or accessibility improvements. Sometimes new owners decide it makes more sense to build fresh locations rather than renovate old ones.
That can be hard for customers who have deep emotional ties to a particular building. A restaurant isn’t just about the food, but about the memories made there. Many diners feel the same about the classic dishes they order again and again, like these diner classics Americans still love.
What Makes a Hometown Restaurant Special
Every region has restaurants like Newport Creamery, places that feel woven into the fabric of local life. They’re where families celebrate report cards, where grandparents take grandkids for a treat and where old friends reconnect when they’re back in town. The food matters, but the sense of belonging matters even more.
When those places close, people often grieve in a way that surprises them. It’s not just losing a menu item, but losing a backdrop to years of birthdays, first dates and quiet lunches with a parent. Many people can name the booth they always sat in or the server who knew their order by heart.
That’s why the news from Providence and Fall River has struck such a chord. Even customers who hadn’t visited in years felt a pang when they heard. For them, the restaurant was a fixed point in a changing world.
Saying Goodbye
For many families in Providence and Fall River, the coming weeks will be a chance to say goodbye. Regulars are likely to stop by for one more meal, one more Awful Awful and one more look around the dining room where they shared so many moments. Some, like Fargnoli, may take home a souvenir to remember it by.
While the closures are sad for longtime customers, the chain’s plans for new locations offer a bit of comfort. Traditions like Bertrand’s monthly cousin lunches will continue somewhere new. And for many New Englanders, the taste of a coffee Awful Awful will always bring back memories of home.
Fans who want to honor the restaurants can also share their favorite memories with family and friends. Old photos from birthday parties and after-school treats are popping up as customers say goodbye. Those stories are a reminder that some places matter far more than their menus.
