7 Holiday Treats That Were Discontinued and Left Families Heartbroken

Every family has a holiday treat that just “has to be there.” Maybe it’s a certain box of cookies on the Christmas cookie tray, a bag of candy that fills the Easter baskets or a seasonal flavor that shows up only when the weather turns cold. These little traditions make the holidays feel like the holidays, even when everything else changes.

That’s why it stings so much when one of them disappears. You head to the store expecting to find the familiar package, and the shelf is empty. Then you learn it isn’t late this year. It’s gone for good, and nobody even sent a warning.

Some of these treats were around for decades, while others had only a few seasons to win hearts. Either way, fans have signed petitions, posted copycat recipes and begged companies to bring them back. Here are seven holiday treats that were discontinued and left families heartbroken.

Christmas jelly candy in a glass dish
Image Credit: rojoimages/Deposit Photos

1. Little Debbie Christmas Spice Cookie Wreaths

For many families, the holidays officially started when the Little Debbie Christmas snacks hit the shelves. Among them were Christmas Spice Cookie Wreaths, little wreath-shaped spice cookies coated in a white glaze and topped with red and green sprinkles. They weren’t fancy, but they were cheerful, and kids loved finding them in their lunch boxes in December.

According to Tasting Table, Little Debbie discontinued the wreaths in 2016. Fans were so upset that they turned to Reddit to share homemade versions. One home baker came up with a copycat recipe, and commenters said it tasted almost exactly like the original. That’s the kind of devotion only a holiday tradition can inspire.

2. Keebler Jingles

Keebler Jingles were a box of pure Christmas cheer. The sugar cookies came in festive shapes like bells, stars, ornaments, trees and wreaths, all topped with red and green sprinkles. Tasting Table notes that the original idea came from an anise-flavored cookie made by a Chicago company called Salerno, which Keebler took over in the 1990s.

For years, a box of Jingles sat on holiday tables right next to the homemade fudge and fruitcake. Then fans noticed they were missing from stores. Tasting Table reports that Keebler confirmed on X in 2020 that its version of Jingles had been discontinued. Salerno-style lookalikes have appeared since, but loyal fans say they’re simply not the same.

3. Nabisco Famous Chocolate Wafers

At first glance, these thin, dark chocolate cookies don’t look like a holiday treat. But for generations of families, Nabisco Famous Chocolate Wafers were the secret to a classic icebox cake. You layered the wafers with whipped cream, let the whole thing sit in the refrigerator overnight and sliced it to reveal pretty stripes. It was a go-to dessert for holiday gatherings that didn’t need an oven.

That’s why the news hit so hard. Tasting Table reports that in 2023, a spokesperson for Mondelēz International confirmed to The Washington Post that the cookies had officially been discontinued. Fans flooded social media to say how much they’d miss them. Home bakers now swap in other cookies, but many say their holiday icebox cake hasn’t been the same since.

4. Hershey’s Pumpkin Spice Kisses

Fall baking season and Thanksgiving gatherings had a special little treat for several years. Hershey’s Pumpkin Spice Kisses featured an orange-colored, cinnamon-flavored white chocolate shell with a creamy white filling. Sporked says they were sold from 2008 to 2019, and fans compared the filling to vanilla cheesecake.

They were the kind of candy that was easy to pour into a dish on the Thanksgiving table or press into the top of a batch of cookies. When they stopped showing up, fans were surprised that Hershey had dropped a pumpkin flavor at a time when pumpkin spice seemed to be in everything. Their absence is still felt every November, along with all the other quirky Thanksgiving traditions families hold onto.

5. Brach’s Marshmallow Easter Hunt Eggs

For many families, Easter baskets weren’t complete without a handful of Brach’s Marshmallow Eggs. These soft, pastel candies had a chewy marshmallow inside and a sugary coating outside. Kids tucked them into plastic eggs for the hunt or simply ate them by the handful while the grownups dyed hard-boiled eggs.

According to The Takeout, shoppers in 2023 couldn’t find the eggs, and that same year Brach’s confirmed it had stopped making them. The official name was Brach’s Marshmallow Easter Hunt Eggs. A few bags may still float around on candy websites, but they’re no longer being produced, and Brach’s hasn’t promised to bring them back.

6. NestlƩ Willy Wonka Weggs

Not every Easter candy was soft and sweet. Willy Wonka Weggs were among the most unusual eggs ever sold. Mental Floss describes them as purple-dyed white chocolate eggs with fillings in bright shades like green and pink. They looked like they came straight out of the movie’s candy factory.

Mental Floss says they were discontinued in 2017 when the Ferrero Group bought the Willy Wonka brand from NestlĆ©. Fans still talk about them online, and one Reddit commenter even wondered if they had been a “fever dream.” For kids who found them in their Easter baskets, they were proof that holiday candy could be a little bit magical.

7. M&M’s Malt Mini Eggs

M&M’s has made plenty of seasonal candy over the years, but one Easter flavor stood out for malt lovers. Tasting Table explains that M&M’s Malt Mini Eggs were a 2016 limited release that hit stores for Easter and then were phased out. They came in pastel colors with a crunchy malted center, a little like a cross between M&M’s and Whoppers.

Because they were only around for one season, some people never got the chance to try them. But those who did still bring them up when talk turns to Easter candy. Fans point out that M&M’s still doesn’t have a malt flavor in its lineup, which is all the more reason to wish these would make a comeback, much like the old-fashioned candies that families still keep in their holiday rotation.

The Treats We Still Set a Place For

Holiday treats carry a weight that ordinary snacks don’t. They come with memories of decorating the tree, hiding eggs in the yard and gathering around a crowded table. When one disappears, it can feel like a small piece of the tradition went with it, which is why so many families keep searching for copycat recipes and close substitutes.

Which discontinued holiday treat do you miss the most? Was it the Christmas cookie tin, the Easter basket candy or a Thanksgiving favorite that never came back? Tell us in the comments, and share the one holiday treat you’d bring back if you could.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *