7 Old-Fashioned Cheeses Disappearing From Supermarket Coolers
Walk down the cheese aisle of a modern supermarket and you’ll find shredded blends, string cheese, sliced pepper jack and fancy imported wedges with names that are hard to pronounce. What you might not find are some of the cheeses that sat in Grandma’s refrigerator for decades.
Many of these old-fashioned cheeses were once ordinary, everyday foods. They were sliced for sandwiches, melted into casseroles, spread on crackers or served with a bowl of soup on a cold night. Over the years, though, changing tastes, big cheese brands and shrinking regional dairies pushed them off many store shelves.
Some of these cheeses are still made, often by just a handful of small producers. But if you’ve tried to find them in an ordinary grocery store lately, you may have come home empty-handed. Here are seven old-time cheeses that have become surprisingly hard to track down.

1. Limburger
Limburger is famous for its strong smell, which has been the punchline of jokes for generations. But for many families of German and Belgian heritage, a slice of Limburger on rye bread with raw onion and mustard was a beloved treat, often enjoyed with a cold beer.
Limburger came to America in the 1800s and was once made by many small dairies run by Swiss and German immigrants. Today, according to the Wisconsin cheese industry, Wisconsin is the only state still producing it. Outside of specialty shops and parts of the Midwest, many supermarkets have stopped carrying it entirely.
Its strong aroma comes from the way it’s made. Cheesemakers wash the rind again and again in brine, which encourages the bacteria that give it its famous funk. Fans insist the flavor is much milder than the smell, but that reputation has kept many younger shoppers from ever giving it a try.
2. Liederkranz
Here’s a cheese many younger shoppers have never heard of. Liederkranz was a soft, rich, washed-rind cheese created in 1891 by a Swiss-born cheesemaker in Monroe, New York. It became so popular that it was sold nationwide for decades and was a favorite for after-dinner cheese plates.
According to its history, production was halted in 1985 after a contaminated batch, and the cheese disappeared for years. It was revived by a Wisconsin company in 2010, but it never regained its old place in supermarket coolers. For many older shoppers, it remains a name they remember from their parents’ table.
3. Brick Cheese
Brick cheese is a true Wisconsin original, first produced there in 1877. It got its name because early makers used actual bricks to press the whey out of the cheese. Young brick cheese is mild and creamy, while aged brick develops a sharper, more pungent flavor.
Brick cheese was once a staple of Midwestern sandwiches and snack trays. It has found new fans as the traditional cheese for Detroit-style pizza, but you’ll still have trouble finding a block of it in many supermarkets outside the Midwest, where mozzarella and cheddar dominate.
4. Real Colby
Colby was invented in 1885 in the small town of Colby, Wisconsin, and it was once one of the most popular cheeses in America. It’s softer, moister and milder than cheddar, with a gentle flavor that kids loved and a texture that was perfect for snacking.
Today, most shoppers know it only as half of Colby-Jack, the marbled orange-and-white blend that fills cheese cases. Plain, old-fashioned Colby on its own has become much harder to find. Many fans say it’s one of those boomer favorites that quietly slipped away without anyone noticing.
5. Hoop Cheese
In the rural South, hoop cheese was a fixture of the country store. Big wheels of the mild, firm, slightly tangy cheese sat on the counter, and the shopkeeper would cut off a wedge and wrap it in paper. It was often eaten with saltine crackers, a slice of bologna or a cold bottle of soda.
Hoop cheese is made in a way that removes much of the whey, which gives it a dry, crumbly texture. As country stores disappeared and supermarkets took over, hoop cheese faded from everyday shopping. It can still be found in some specialty and Southern stores, but many younger shoppers have never tasted it.
6. Port Wine Cheese Spread
A crock of rose-colored port wine cheese spread was a must at holiday parties for decades. It was spread on crackers, served at bridge clubs and given in gift baskets every December. Cold-pack cheese spreads like this were especially popular in the Midwest and still have a following there.
While these spreads are still made, they have become a lot less common in ordinary grocery stores. Fancy charcuterie boards and imported cheeses have taken their place at many gatherings. For people who grew up with them, though, a cheese ball or crock of port wine spread still means the holidays.
7. Farmer Cheese
Farmer cheese is a simple, fresh cheese made by pressing curds until much of the liquid is gone, leaving a firm, crumbly cheese with a mild, slightly tangy taste. It was a staple in many Eastern European and Jewish households, used in blintzes, pierogi, cheesecakes and savory fillings.
Grandmothers who made their own blintzes or pierogi always knew where to find it. Today, many supermarkets carry only cottage cheese and ricotta, leaving farmer cheese to delis and specialty stores. Some home cooks now make it themselves rather than hunt for it on store shelves.
Why These Cheeses Are Fading
Several things have pushed these cheeses aside. Big national brands have focused on a few best-selling varieties like cheddar, mozzarella and Swiss. Many small regional dairies that made specialty cheeses have closed or merged over the decades. And busy shoppers now reach for pre-shredded and pre-sliced cheese more than whole blocks.
Tastes have changed, too. Strong-smelling cheeses like Limburger fell out of fashion, and younger shoppers lean toward imported cheeses they see on cooking shows. Many grocery stores simply don’t have room for cheeses that only a few customers buy.
Where to Look for Them Today
If you’re missing one of these old favorites, it may still be out there. Specialty cheese shops, Midwestern dairies, delis and Amish or Mennonite markets often carry varieties that supermarkets have dropped. Some cheesemakers also sell directly by mail order, especially around the holidays.
Which of these cheeses did your family keep in the refrigerator? And is there an old-fashioned cheese you still go out of your way to find?
