9 Things Grandma Added to Her Coffee That Most People Wouldn’t Try Today
Coffee has been part of American mornings for a very long time. The National Coffee Association notes that coffee reached what is now New York City in the mid-1600s, and that after the Boston Tea Party, Americans began turning from tea to coffee for good. By the time our grandmothers were brewing it, the percolator on the stove was the heartbeat of the kitchen.
But Grandma’s cup didn’t always look like ours. She didn’t have flavored creamers, oat milk or a menu of syrups from the drive-thru. Instead, she worked with what was in the pantry, and some of her favorite add-ins sound downright strange today.
Some of these came from old-country traditions, some came from tight budgets and a few were just family habits passed down. Here are nine things Grandma added to her coffee that most people wouldn’t dream of trying today.

1. A Whole Raw Egg
This one surprises almost everyone. In many Scandinavian-American homes, especially in Minnesota and the Upper Midwest, cooks made what’s known as egg coffee. They cracked a raw egg, sometimes shell and all, into the coffee grounds, stirred it into a paste and then boiled it in water.
The egg caught the grounds and helped clear the coffee as it cooked. After a quick splash of cold water, the grounds sank to the bottom, and what was left was a smooth, light cup with very little bitterness. It became a favorite at Lutheran church suppers and big family gatherings, where it was brewed in huge pots. Many people who grew up with it still say it’s the best coffee they’ve ever had.
2. Crushed Eggshells
Some grandmothers skipped the whole egg and saved the shells instead. After breakfast, they rinsed and crushed the eggshells and tossed them into the pot with the grounds. It was a thrifty kitchen trick that used something most people would throw away.
Cooks believed the shells helped settle the grounds and cut the harsh, bitter taste of cheap coffee. It’s a habit that came from a time when nothing went to waste. Mention it to a younger coffee drinker today, though, and you’ll probably get a puzzled look.
3. A Pinch of Salt
Plenty of older cooks swore by a tiny pinch of salt in the coffee pot or right in the cup. It sounds odd, but the idea was to smooth out bitter flavors, especially when the coffee was old, cheap or brewed too long. Many people who grew up on percolator coffee remember their mothers and grandmothers doing it.
It wasn’t about making the coffee salty. Just a few grains were enough to take the edge off. The habit still pops up in some homes today, but most younger people are shocked to learn that salt ever went near a cup of coffee.
4. Chicory
In New Orleans and across much of Louisiana, coffee often comes with a little something extra: roasted chicory root. It adds a deep, almost chocolatey flavor and a slightly bitter edge. For generations, many families stretched their coffee by blending in chicory, especially in lean times when coffee beans were scarce or costly.
The tradition is still alive at famous spots like CafĆ© du Monde, which has served coffee in the New Orleans French Market since 1862 and lists coffee and chicory on its menu. It’s often served au lait, which means half coffee and half hot milk. Outside the South, though, most younger people have never tasted it.
5. Canned Evaporated Milk
Before cartons of half-and-half and bottles of flavored creamer, many grandmothers reached for a can of evaporated milk. They’d punch two holes in the top with a can opener and pour a thick, creamy stream right into the cup. The can often sat on the table or in the fridge door with a little cover on top.
Canned milk had been part of American kitchens for a long time. According to Pet, the company began in Highland, Illinois, in 1885 with the idea of canning milk, and it became a household staple during the Great Depression. For many families, that slightly caramel flavor in the coffee is a taste of childhood that store-bought creamer never quite matches.
6. A Splash of Whiskey
On cold nights, holidays or after a long day, some grandparents liked a little splash of something stronger in their coffee. Whiskey, brandy or rum turned an ordinary cup into a warming treat. It was a way to relax with friends after dinner or to toast a special occasion.
The most famous version is Irish coffee, which became a hit in America after a challenge at a San Francisco bar. The Buena Vista Cafe says its owner and a travel writer set out on November 10, 1952, to recreate the Irish coffee served at Shannon Airport in Ireland. The cafe now serves up to 2,000 of them a day, but many grandparents simply added a splash at the kitchen table.
7. Cardamom
In some Scandinavian and Middle Eastern households, coffee and cardamom have long gone together. A few crushed pods dropped in with the grounds gave the coffee a warm, floral, slightly citrusy flavor. It was a taste of the old country for many immigrant families.
Cardamom was also a favorite in Swedish baking, so it was natural for some families to add it to their morning cup. Today, you might find it in a fancy coffee shop special, but few people would think to keep cardamom pods next to the coffee can at home. For grandmothers who grew up with it, though, plain coffee just tasted flat.
8. Sweetened Condensed Milk
Some families used sweetened condensed milk in place of both cream and sugar. A spoonful or two stirred into hot coffee made it thick, sweet and rich. It was a popular choice in homes where fresh milk was hard to come by or didn’t keep well.
Many people who grew up in the South, in military families or in households with roots in Latin America and Southeast Asia remember this habit. It was cheap, it lasted a long time in the pantry and it made coffee feel like dessert. Most younger coffee drinkers today wouldn’t think to open a can of it outside of baking season.
9. A Cube of Cheese
This one might be the strangest of all. In some Finnish and Swedish families, especially in the far north, coffee was served with small cubes of a firm, squeaky cheese dropped right into the cup. The cheese warmed and softened in the hot coffee and was scooped out with a spoon at the end.
Families with roots in northern Scandinavia sometimes carried this tradition to the Upper Midwest. It’s still a novelty that people try when they visit those regions. For most Americans, though, the idea of cheese in coffee sounds like a joke, even if some grandmothers considered it a real treat.
The Coffee Cup Tells a Story
These add-ins say a lot about where our families came from and how they lived. Some were about stretching a tight budget, some were about making cheap coffee taste better and others were about holding on to traditions from home. There are plenty of surprising coffee facts out there, but few are as personal as what went into Grandma’s cup.
If you’re feeling bold, you could even try one of these the next time you set up a coffee bar at home. So what did your grandmother put in her coffee? Was it eggshells, a pinch of salt or something even stranger? Tell us in the comments.
