8 Old Apple Varieties You Won’t Find at the Supermarket
Walk into any grocery store in America, and the apple bin looks pretty much the same from coast to coast. Gala, Fuji, Honeycrisp, Granny Smith and Red Delicious fill most of the space, with maybe a newer variety like Cosmic Crisp thrown in. It’s easy to assume those are the only apples that matter.
But America once grew an astonishing variety of apples. Farms and backyard orchards were filled with thousands of different kinds, each with its own flavor, color and purpose. Some were best for pies, others for cider and some were meant to be stored in the cellar all winter, getting sweeter by the month.
Most of those old varieties disappeared from stores long ago, pushed aside by apples that shipped well, looked shiny and stayed firm for months. A handful survive in old orchards, at farmers markets and in the care of devoted growers. Here are some of the old apple varieties your grandparents or great-grandparents may have known, and why you won’t find them at the supermarket.

1. Roxbury Russet
The Roxbury Russet is often called the oldest apple variety bred in America. It’s believed to have come from Roxbury, Massachusetts, in the early 1600s, not long after the Pilgrims arrived. Colonists valued it because it stored well through long New England winters.
It isn’t much to look at. The skin is rough and brownish-green, a texture known as russeting. But the flesh is crisp and sweet-tart, and it was prized for making cider. That rough, dull appearance is a big reason it never made it into modern supermarkets, where shoppers expect apples to look glossy and bright.
2. Esopus Spitzenburg
This apple has a famous fan. Thomas Jefferson grew Esopus Spitzenburg trees at Monticello and reportedly considered it one of his favorite apples. It originated in the Esopus area of New York’s Hudson Valley in the 1700s.
The Spitzenburg is a striking red apple with a rich, spicy flavor that many people say tastes complex, almost like wine. It’s wonderful for eating fresh and for baking. But the trees can be finicky and prone to disease, which made them harder for commercial orchards to grow on a large scale.
3. Newtown Pippin
The Newtown Pippin has one of the longest and most distinguished histories of any American apple. It originated on Long Island in the early 1700s and became one of the first American apples to gain fame in Europe. According to Mother Earth News, it was Benjamin Franklin’s favorite, and Jefferson grew it at Monticello too.
It’s a greenish-yellow apple with a tangy flavor that gets better after a few weeks of storage. It was once widely grown for eating, cooking and cider. Today, it’s mostly grown in small quantities, and you’re more likely to find it at a specialty orchard than a chain grocery store.
4. Baldwin
For much of the 1800s and early 1900s, the Baldwin was one of the most popular apples in New England and New York. It was a sturdy red apple that stored and shipped well, and it was a favorite for eating, baking and cider. Farmers planted it everywhere.
Its downfall came from the weather. A brutally cold winter in the 1930s killed huge numbers of Baldwin trees across the Northeast. Many farmers replanted with hardier varieties like the McIntosh instead, and the Baldwin never fully recovered. Today, it’s mostly found in old orchards and heritage collections.
5. Northern Spy
Ask an old-time New England or Michigan baker about the best pie apple, and you might hear about the Northern Spy. It’s a large, red-striped apple with a tart, juicy flavor that holds its shape beautifully in a pie. Many bakers swore by it.
The problem was the tree. Northern Spy trees can take many years to start producing fruit, sometimes close to a decade, which made them a tough sell for commercial growers who wanted a quicker return. You can still find Northern Spies in some regional orchards in the fall, but they’re rarely sold in big supermarkets. They’re a favorite for classic American pies when you can get them.
6. Arkansas Black
The Arkansas Black is one of the most striking apples you’ll ever see. Its skin turns such a deep, dark red that it looks almost black, especially after storage. It originated in Arkansas in the 1800s and became a favorite in the South.
When freshly picked, the Arkansas Black is incredibly hard, almost too hard to bite comfortably. But after a few months in cold storage, it softens and develops a rich, sweet flavor with hints of cherry and spice. That need for patience is part of why it never became a supermarket staple, though it has a loyal following among apple lovers.
7. Rhode Island Greening
The Rhode Island Greening is a classic early American apple that dates back to the 1600s in, as you might guess, Rhode Island. It’s a large green apple with a sharp, tart flavor that was considered one of the best for pies and applesauce.
For many years, it was a standard cooking apple in the Northeast. Over time, though, Granny Smith became the go-to green apple in supermarkets, partly because it shipped well and was available year-round. The Rhode Island Greening is still grown in some orchards, but it’s become a hard-to-find heirloom.
8. Winter Banana
The Winter Banana is a pale yellow apple with a pink blush, and it gets its name from a surprising trait. Many people say it has a faint banana-like aroma, especially when ripe. It was discovered in Indiana in the late 1800s.
It’s a pretty, mild apple that was popular in home orchards. But its delicate skin bruises easily, which makes it a poor choice for shipping long distances. Like many old varieties, it was simply too fragile for the modern grocery system.
Why the Old Apples Disappeared
Most of these apples faded for the same reasons. As the grocery business grew, growers focused on apples that produced heavy crops, shipped without bruising, stored for months and looked shiny and uniform. Flavor was often less important than appearance and durability.
The classic example is the Red Delicious, which was bred over the decades for its deep red color and sturdy skin, sometimes at the expense of taste. Farmers’ Almanac has a good look at how that apple changed over time. Many shoppers who grew up on mealy Red Delicious apples never knew what they were missing.
Where to Find Heirloom Apples
The good news is that heirloom apples are making a quiet comeback. Many orchards now grow a few old varieties for pick-your-own customers and farm stands. Farmers markets in the fall often have surprising selections, and some specialty grocers carry heirlooms for a few weeks each year.
If you’ve never tasted one, it’s worth seeking them out. You might find a flavor that reminds you of your grandparents’ orchard. Do you remember any old apple varieties from your childhood, and which one made the best pie?
