9 Southern Thanksgiving Sides Northerners Have Never Heard Of

Thanksgiving is one of the few meals nearly every American family sits down to on the same day. But if you’ve ever spent the holiday in a different part of the country, you know the menu can look very different from one region to the next. Nowhere is that more true than in the South.

Turkey may be the star everywhere, but Southern tables are loaded with side dishes that leave many Northerners confused. Some are rich casseroles that blur the line between side dish and dessert. Others are old family traditions that go back generations and rarely travel north of the Mason-Dixon line.

If you married into a Southern family or moved down South, you may have had a few surprises at your first Thanksgiving. Here are the Southern Thanksgiving sides many Northerners have never heard of, or simply can’t believe people eat alongside the turkey.

Plate of Southern collard greens
Image Credit: MonaMakela/Deposit Photos

1. Cornbread Dressing

In much of the North, Thanksgiving means bread stuffing, often cooked inside the bird. In the South, it’s cornbread dressing, and Southerners will tell you there’s a big difference. It starts with a skillet of crumbled cornbread, mixed with onions, celery, sage, broth and eggs, then baked in a pan until golden on top.

Many Southern families wouldn’t dream of using white bread, and some add biscuits or sausage to the mix. Calling it “stuffing” in front of a Southern grandmother may earn you a correction. For a look at more classic Southern dishes with deep roots, there’s plenty to explore beyond the holiday table.

2. Squash Casserole

Squash casserole is a beloved Southern side made from yellow summer squash, onions, cheese and eggs, often topped with crushed buttery crackers or breadcrumbs. It’s creamy, cheesy and comforting, and it shows up at church suppers, potlucks and holiday tables across the South.

Northerners often assume squash means butternut or acorn squash in the fall. Yellow squash at Thanksgiving can come as a surprise. But once they try it, many become fans. Garden & Gun has a classic version that captures the spirit of the dish.

3. Pineapple Casserole

This may be the most puzzling dish of all for Northerners. Pineapple casserole combines canned pineapple chunks, sugar, flour and shredded cheddar cheese, topped with crushed buttery crackers and melted butter. It’s baked until bubbly and served right alongside the turkey and ham.

Yes, it’s pineapple and cheddar together. The combination sounds strange to many people, but fans say the sweet, tangy, salty mix is addictive. It’s especially popular with ham, and in many Southern homes it shows up at Easter and Christmas as well as Thanksgiving.

4. Ambrosia

Ambrosia is an old-fashioned fruit salad that has been part of Southern holidays for well over a century. The original versions were simple, made with fresh oranges, grated coconut and a little sugar. Over time, many families added pineapple, maraschino cherries, marshmallows, pecans and whipped cream or sour cream.

In the 1800s, oranges and coconut were expensive and hard to come by, which made ambrosia a special-occasion treat. As Chowhound explains, it was once something of a status symbol. Today, it’s a nostalgic dish that divides families, with some loving it and others pushing it to the far end of the table.

5. Congealed Salad

In the South, a “congealed salad” is a gelatin dish, often made with fruit, nuts, cream cheese or whipped topping, set in a mold or a dish. Popular versions include cranberry congealed salad, lime with pineapple and cottage cheese and strawberry pretzel salad, which has a crunchy pretzel crust on the bottom.

Northerners are often confused by the word “salad” being applied to something that looks a lot like dessert. But in many Southern families, these dishes are a must at Thanksgiving. Grandmothers often had a signature version that the whole family looked forward to every year.

6. Chitterlings

Chitterlings, often called chitlins, are pig intestines that are cleaned, boiled and sometimes fried. They have deep roots in Southern and African American cooking and are especially associated with the holidays. Cleaning them is a long, labor-intensive job, which is one reason many families only make them once or twice a year.

For some families, chitlins are a cherished Thanksgiving or Christmas tradition passed down for generations. The Southern Foodways Alliance has written about the care and family history that go into preparing them. Many Northerners have never tasted them, and the strong smell while they cook is famous.

7. Rice Dressing

In Louisiana and parts of the Gulf Coast, rice dressing often takes the place of bread stuffing. Sometimes called dirty rice, it’s made with rice cooked with ground meat, chicken livers or giblets, onions, celery, bell pepper and Cajun seasonings. The result is savory, rich and deeply flavorful.

Rice dressing reflects Louisiana’s history of rice farming and its Cajun and Creole traditions. Many families serve it alongside cornbread dressing, so both are on the table. To Northerners, rice at Thanksgiving can seem unexpected, but in Louisiana it would feel strange not to have it.

8. Oyster Dressing

Oyster dressing is an old coastal tradition that goes back centuries in parts of the South, especially along the Gulf Coast and in the Carolinas and Virginia. Fresh oysters are mixed into a cornbread or bread dressing with butter, onions and herbs, then baked. The oysters add a briny, savory richness.

Oysters were once plentiful and inexpensive along the coast, so they made their way into many holiday dishes. Today, oyster dressing is less common than it used to be, but many coastal families still make it every year. Northerners who aren’t fans of seafood are often surprised to find it on the Thanksgiving table.

9. Collard Greens

Collard greens are a staple of Southern cooking, and many families serve them at Thanksgiving. The greens are slowly simmered with smoked turkey, ham hocks or bacon until tender, creating a flavorful broth called pot likker. A splash of vinegar or hot sauce is a common finishing touch.

In the North, greens aren’t a typical Thanksgiving side, and many people only know collards from soul food restaurants. But in much of the South, a big pot of greens is as essential as the turkey. Many families serve them with cornbread to soak up every drop of the broth.

Every Region Has Its Traditions

The South isn’t the only region with its own Thanksgiving specialties. The Midwest has its Jell-O salads and hotdishes, New England has its own takes on stuffing and squash and the Southwest often adds a little heat. Those regional differences are part of what makes the holiday so interesting. Here’s a look at the most common Thanksgiving side dishes across the country.

No matter where you’re from, Thanksgiving is about sharing family favorites with the people you love. Which of these Southern sides have you tried, and which one would you never put on your Thanksgiving table?

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *