Leftover Turkey Stays Moist When You Reheat It With This

The day after Thanksgiving has a magic of its own. The pressure is off, the house is quiet and the refrigerator is packed with leftovers. For many families, the turkey sandwich, the second plate of stuffing and the cold slice of pie are just as good as the feast itself.

But there’s one leftover that often disappoints: reheated turkey. A slice that was juicy on Thursday can come out of the microwave on Friday dry, tough and stringy. Many people end up drowning it in gravy just to make it edible, or they give up and eat it cold.

There’s a simple fix that experienced cooks have used for generations, and it’s probably already in your pantry or refrigerator. The secret is broth. Here’s why it works, how to use it and a few other tips for keeping leftover turkey moist and tasty.

Leftover Turkey Stays Moist When You Reheat It With This
Image Credit: resnick_joshua1/Deposit Photos

Why Leftover Turkey Dries Out

Turkey, especially white breast meat, is very lean. It doesn’t have much fat to keep it moist, which is why it can dry out quickly when it’s reheated. When turkey is heated a second time, it loses more of its moisture, and the meat fibers tighten up, leaving it tough.

Microwaves can make the problem worse. They heat food unevenly, and the edges of a slice can dry out and turn rubbery while the center is still cold. That’s why so many people are disappointed when they try to reheat a plate of turkey in a hurry.

The Secret: A Splash of Broth

The easiest way to keep reheated turkey moist is to add a little chicken or turkey broth. The broth adds moisture back to the meat as it warms, creating gentle steam that keeps the turkey tender. It also adds flavor, so the turkey tastes savory and fresh rather than flat.

Many cooks use broth whether they’re reheating turkey in the oven, on the stovetop or in the microwave. The key is to cover the turkey so the steam stays in. A little broth goes a long way, and the difference is noticeable right away.

How to Reheat Turkey in the Oven

The oven is one of the best ways to reheat a larger amount of turkey. Place the slices or pieces in a baking dish and pour a few spoonfuls of broth over them, just enough to cover the bottom of the dish. Some cooks add a small pat of butter for extra richness.

Cover the dish tightly with aluminum foil to trap the steam. Then reheat it in a moderate oven, around 300 to 325 degrees, until it’s warmed through. Low and slow is the goal, since high heat can dry the turkey out. This method works especially well for feeding the family a second Thanksgiving dinner.

How to Reheat Turkey on the Stovetop

For smaller amounts, the stovetop is quick and easy. Add a splash of broth to a skillet and warm it over medium-low heat. Add the turkey slices, cover the pan with a lid and let them heat gently in the steamy broth for a few minutes.

Turn the slices once or twice so they heat evenly. The broth will keep them moist and tender, and the turkey will soak up some of the flavor. This method is perfect for making hot turkey sandwiches or a quick lunch.

How to Reheat Turkey in the Microwave

If you’re in a hurry, the microwave can still work, as long as you add moisture. Place the turkey on a microwave-safe plate or dish and drizzle a spoonful or two of broth over it. Then cover it with a microwave-safe lid or a damp paper towel.

Heat it in short bursts, checking and turning the pieces in between. Using a lower power setting can help the turkey heat more evenly. With a little broth and a cover, microwaved turkey can come out much juicier than usual.

Reheat It Safely

Food safety matters with leftovers. The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s food safety basics say leftovers should be reheated to an internal temperature of 165 degrees Fahrenheit. A food thermometer is the easiest way to check.

The USDA also advises refrigerating leftovers within two hours of cooking and using most cooked leftovers within three to four days, or freezing them for longer storage. Frozen turkey keeps its best quality for a few months, so many families freeze a few bags for quick dinners in December. Making room before the holiday helps, and a quick fridge and freezer check before the big grocery run makes the leftovers easier to store.

Store It Smart in the First Place

How you store your turkey also affects how it reheats. Many cooks recommend carving the meat off the bones before refrigerating it, since a whole carcass takes up space and cools slowly. Storing the turkey in shallow containers helps it chill quickly and evenly.

Some cooks even add a spoonful of broth or gravy to the container before refrigerating the turkey. That helps keep the meat from drying out in the refrigerator and gives it a head start when it’s time to reheat. Dark meat, which has more fat, tends to stay moist longer than white meat.

Other Ways to Use Leftover Turkey

If you’d rather not reheat slices, there are plenty of ways to give leftover turkey new life. Turkey soup, turkey pot pie, turkey tetrazzini and turkey enchiladas all use broth or sauce, which keeps the meat moist. Shredded turkey also works well in casseroles and fried rice.

Many families have a favorite leftover recipe that they look forward to all year. For some, the day-after turkey sandwich with cranberry sauce and stuffing is the best meal of the whole holiday. Here are some classic side dishes that pair just as well with leftovers.

Make Your Own Broth From the Carcass

Here’s a bonus tip: the turkey carcass can be turned into homemade broth. Simmer the bones with onion, carrots, celery and a few herbs for several hours, then strain it. You’ll have a rich, flavorful broth that’s perfect for reheating leftover turkey or making soup.

Many grandmothers made turkey broth every year, and nothing went to waste. It’s a thrifty, old-fashioned habit that’s making a comeback in many kitchens.

How do you reheat your leftover turkey? And what’s your family’s favorite way to use up Thanksgiving leftovers?

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *