Shopping at Kroger Instead of Walmart Can Cost a Couple About $1,000 a Year, and Kroger’s CEO Admits It Isn’t Trying to Be the Cheapest

Where you buy your groceries can make a bigger difference to your budget than you might think. A new analysis suggests that a retired couple who does all their grocery shopping at Kroger instead of Walmart could be spending about $1,000 more a year for the same basket of name-brand groceries.

The estimate comes from a November 9 report by 24/7 Wall St., which used price data from a Consumer Reports survey and comments from the heads of two of America’s biggest supermarket companies. The leaders of both Kroger and Albertsons have openly acknowledged that Walmart’s prices are lower, and they’ve signaled that the gap isn’t going away anytime soon.

For shoppers who’ve been loyal to their neighborhood supermarket for decades, the numbers are eye-opening. Here’s what the report found and what grocery executives are saying about it.

Supermarket shelves
Image Credit: Deposit Photos

What Consumer Reports Found

The analysis is based on a Consumer Reports survey that priced the same basket of national-brand groceries at 35 chains in six metro areas in late summer 2025, then compared each chain with Walmart. According to 24/7 Wall St., Kroger’s prices came in 14.8% higher than Walmart’s for the same basket.

Other traditional supermarkets were even more expensive. Publix was 20.3% higher than Walmart, and Albertsons was 24.8% higher. Albertsons owns many familiar store names, including Safeway, Vons, Jewel-Osco, Acme and Shaw’s.

On the other end, a few chains beat Walmart’s prices. Costco came in about 21.4% cheaper, BJ’s Wholesale about 21% cheaper, Lidl about 8.5% cheaper and Aldi about 8.3% cheaper. Aldi’s advantage varied by city, from about 4% in Los Angeles to more than 16% in Virginia Beach.

How the $1,000 Figure Was Calculated

The report used the example of a retired couple in Texas who spend about $650 a month, or $7,800 a year, on groceries at Kroger. Applying the 14.8% price gap, the same basket would cost about $6,794 a year at Walmart. That’s a difference of about $1,006 a year, or roughly $84 a month.

For the same couple, the report estimated the basket would cost about $8,174 at Publix and $8,479 at Albertsons, compared with about $6,230 at Aldi and $5,340 at Costco before the membership fee. Of course, shoppers buy different items, and prices vary by store and region, so a real family’s numbers could be higher or lower.

What Kroger’s CEO Said

Kroger CEO Greg Foran was unusually candid during a September earnings call. “We’re not in the game of being the cheapest because we don’t have the lowest costs, but we can provide the best value,” he said, according to the report.

Foran said Kroger knows what its price gap with Walmart should be and is using cost savings to fund price cuts. But he also said the company can’t make those cuts all at once, which means the gap is likely to narrow slowly, if at all. Kroger has announced plans to spend billions on lowering prices over time.

What Albertsons’ CEO Said

Albertsons CEO Susan Morris has also acknowledged the competition. “Our biggest leakage is to the big players: Walmart, Amazon, and, to some degree, Aldi, as a price-competitive player,” she said on an earnings call.

In other words, Albertsons knows many of its customers are buying at least some of their groceries elsewhere to save money. That’s a familiar story for traditional supermarkets, which have been losing share to discount chains and warehouse clubs for years.

Why Supermarkets Cost More

Traditional supermarkets have higher costs than many discount chains. They often have larger service departments, such as full-service delis, bakeries, meat counters and pharmacies. They may also have more staff, older buildings and higher labor costs because of union contracts.

Walmart, on the other hand, uses its enormous size to negotiate lower prices from suppliers and keep costs down. Aldi and Lidl keep prices low with smaller stores, fewer brands and a focus on store-label products. Warehouse clubs like Costco sell in bulk and charge membership fees.

Why Many Shoppers Stay Loyal Anyway

Despite the price difference, millions of shoppers still choose Kroger, Publix, Albertsons and other supermarkets. Many say they prefer the shopping experience, the selection, the fresh produce and meat, or the convenience of a store close to home.

Others use supermarket loyalty programs, digital coupons and weekly sales to lower their costs. Kroger’s fuel points and personalized deals, for example, can make a real difference for frequent shoppers. Some families split their shopping, buying pantry staples at a discount store and fresh items at their favorite supermarket.

What This Means for Retirees

For retirees on fixed incomes, a $1,000-a-year difference is significant. That’s money that could cover a month or two of utility bills, a few months of prescriptions or holiday gifts for the grandkids. As grocery prices remain high, many older shoppers are paying closer attention to where they shop.

Many retirees say they’ve already started mixing stores, using Aldi or Walmart for basics and their longtime supermarket for special items. Others have joined warehouse clubs to buy in bulk. Plenty of older shoppers still remember how their parents made every dollar count, and those habits are coming back.

Prices Vary by Region

It’s important to note that grocery prices vary widely from one city to another. The Consumer Reports survey looked at six metro areas, and the gap between stores can be larger or smaller depending on where you live. A Kroger in one city may be closer to Walmart’s prices than a Kroger somewhere else.

Store sales, digital coupons and loyalty discounts also make a big difference. Shoppers who regularly use their supermarket’s deals may pay much less than the regular shelf prices used in surveys.

For many families, the decision comes down to time as well as money. Driving to a cheaper store across town costs gas and time, and some shoppers say the savings aren’t worth it once those costs are counted. Others say every dollar matters on a fixed income.

Will the Gap Close?

According to the report, no grocery company has promised to fully close the gap with Walmart. Kroger says it can narrow the difference over several years, but doing so takes money, and supermarket chains face pressure to stay profitable.

For now, the price gap is a fact of life for American grocery shoppers. Whether it’s worth paying more for a favorite store comes down to what each family values most: price, convenience, quality or the friendly cashier who has known them for 20 years.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *