A Mom Says a HomeGoods Cashier Shamed Her for Saying No to a St. Jude Donation, but Her Own Son Had Been Turned Away
Almost everyone has heard the question at the register: “Would you like to round up your purchase for charity today?” Most people say yes or no without thinking twice. But for one mother, a simple “no” at a HomeGoods checkout turned into an uncomfortable moment that she later shared with thousands of people online.
Emily Rednour, who posts on TikTok as @letterstorowen and runs a local nonprofit for children with cancer, says a HomeGoods cashier gave her a “dirty look” after she declined to round up her total for St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital. Her account, which Yahoo Lifestyle reported on November 17, has sparked a big debate about checkout donation requests and how much pressure shoppers should feel to give.
What makes her story especially striking is her reason for saying no. She says her own son was turned down by St. Jude. Here’s what happened, according to her account, and why so many people are talking about it.

What She Says Happened at the Register
According to Rednour, she was checking out at a HomeGoods store one morning when the cashier asked whether she wanted to round up her purchase for St. Jude. She said no. Instead of moving on, she says, the cashier gave her a look and asked if she was sure, adding that the store was donating a lot.
“I just felt like, what are you implying?” Rednour said in her video, as reported by Yahoo Lifestyle. She says that when she was asked again, she agreed to round up, and the cashier’s attitude changed right away. The cashier then began talking warmly about how the donations help children with cancer.
It’s important to note that this is her side of the story. The cashier’s account isn’t known, and the report doesn’t include a response from HomeGoods.
“My Son Was Denied by St. Jude”
Rednour says she told the cashier, “My son was denied by St. Jude,” and explained that not every child is accepted at the famous Memphis hospital. That detail is what made her video stand out, because many people assume St. Jude accepts any child with cancer.
In her video, Rednour said she respects St. Jude’s work but believes its advertising leaves some people with the wrong impression. “Their cure rate is based off of the children they accept,” she said. Her son’s case and the reasons he wasn’t accepted were not independently confirmed in the report.
How St. Jude Decides Who to Accept
St. Jude is known for its promise that families never receive a bill for treatment, travel, housing or food. But the hospital does have admission criteria. According to the report and the hospital’s own patient information, St. Jude generally accepts patients 21 or younger who are referred by a doctor and who have a disease the hospital currently treats and studies, often through clinical research trials.
Families can read about the referral process on St. Jude’s website. The hospital’s focus on research means some children aren’t eligible, even though St. Jude does not turn patients away because of a family’s ability to pay. That nuance is exactly what Rednour says she wanted people to understand.
Why She Gives Elsewhere
Rednour said she prefers to give to her own nonprofit, which she says helps “thousands of families” dealing with pediatric cancer. She noted that her organization doesn’t have the marketing budget of a large national charity like St. Jude.
She also made a broader point about judging people at the register. “You just never know who you’re talking to, who they are, what they do for work, what they’re involved in,” she said. A shopper who says no might already be giving in other ways, or might be dealing with something painful the cashier can’t see.
The Bigger Debate About Checkout Donations
Rednour’s story struck a nerve because so many shoppers feel uneasy about being asked to donate at the register. Retailers across the country, from grocery stores to big-box chains, ask customers to round up or add a dollar for various causes. Many of these campaigns raise millions of dollars for good organizations.
But some shoppers say the requests can feel like pressure, especially when a cashier repeats the question or reacts badly to a “no.” Others feel guilty saying no in front of people in line. Many people say they prefer to choose their own charities and give directly, rather than at the checkout.
The debate is similar to the one over tipping. Just as many Americans feel tipping has gone too far with screens asking for tips everywhere, some feel checkout donation requests have become too frequent and too pushy.
What Cashiers Are Up Against
It’s also fair to remember the cashier’s position. In some stores, employees are encouraged to ask every customer, and some report feeling pressure to hit donation goals. A cashier who asks “Are you sure?” may simply be following what they were told to do, not trying to shame anyone.
Many retail workers say they don’t take a “no” personally and would never judge a customer for it. But even one awkward exchange can leave a shopper feeling embarrassed, and in a world where people film and share their experiences, those moments can quickly reach a big audience.
What Shoppers Can Do
Saying no to a checkout donation is perfectly acceptable. A simple “No, thank you” is enough, and shoppers don’t owe anyone an explanation. Many people choose to give directly to charities they’ve researched, which can also make it easier to track donations for tax purposes.
If a cashier makes you uncomfortable, you can mention it politely to a store manager. Most stores want their customers to feel welcome, whether they donate or not. And if you do want to give, rounding up is an easy way to help a good cause.
Some viewers who commented on similar stories said they now decline every checkout donation simply to avoid the pressure, while others said they always round up because the amount is so small. The debate shows how personal charitable giving can be.
A Reminder to Be Kind at the Register
At its heart, Rednour’s story is a reminder that everyone in line has their own life and struggles. A mother saying no to a children’s hospital donation might be the last person you’d expect to have a child with cancer.
Whether you round up or not, the moment at the checkout should be simple and respectful on both sides. And as Rednour put it, you never know who you’re talking to.
