New York’s Governor Just Vetoed a Ban on 3 Food Additives Found in Pizza, Bagels and Candy
New Yorkers love their pizza and bagels, and that love just played a big part in a statewide food fight. Gov. Kathy Hochul is vetoing a bill that would have banned three food additives in New York and required food makers to share more information about some of the ingredients they use. Supporters had hoped New York would join the states pushing for tougher food rules, but the governor said the cost was too high.
The decision has disappointed food safety advocates who lobbied for months to get the bill passed. Business groups and restaurant owners, on the other hand, had warned that the ban could drive up prices on everyday foods. Here is what the bill would have done, why Hochul rejected it and what could happen next.

What the Bill Would Have Banned
The bill targeted three ingredients that critics have questioned for years. According to WSKG, they were FD&C Red No. 3, propylparaben and potassium bromate. Each one shows up in different kinds of foods that many shoppers buy without a second thought.
Red No. 3 is a synthetic dye that gives some candies, frostings and baked goods a bright cherry-red color. Propylparaben is a preservative that has been used in some packaged baked goods to extend shelf life. Potassium bromate is used by some bakers to strengthen dough and help it rise, which is why it came up again and again in discussions about pizza and bagels.
The bill also would have required makers of packaged foods to disclose more information about certain ingredients. This part was aimed at substances known as GRAS, short for “generally recognized as safe,” a category that allows some ingredients to be added to food without a full FDA review.
Why Pizza and Bagel Makers Pushed Back
New York’s famous pizza and bagel shops became the face of the opposition. Many business groups and restaurant owners opposed the ban, especially the part that would have removed potassium bromate. Some bakers worried they would have to change recipes that customers have loved for decades.
Restaurant owners also raised concerns about the cost of switching to other ingredients and suppliers. For small shops already dealing with higher rents, wages and food prices, any extra expense can be hard to absorb. Those concerns appear to have weighed heavily on the governor’s decision.
What Hochul’s Office Said
A spokesperson for the governor explained the decision with a line that quickly caught attention. “When it comes to New York’s famous pizza and bagels, the only thing that should rise is the dough, not the cost,” the spokesperson said, according to the report.
The governor’s office added that while the goal of the bill was “laudable,” putting it into effect now would hurt New York businesses and make groceries more expensive for families. The statement also said it would raise costs for taxpayers. Instead of a state ban, Hochul’s office urged the FDA to keep reviewing food ingredients and strengthen its oversight.
The plan to veto was first reported by the New York Post before it was confirmed by other outlets. The veto was one of several decisions the governor faced on bills passed by the Legislature this year.
The FDA Is Already Acting on Red No. 3
One of the three additives is already on its way out nationwide. The FDA has moved to ban Red No. 3 from food, with the ban beginning in January, according to the report. The agency’s own explanation of the decision says it revoked authorization for the dye in food and ingested drugs.
That means New York shoppers will likely see Red No. 3 disappear from many products anyway, even without the state law. However, propylparaben and potassium bromate remain permitted under federal rules. Advocates had hoped New York would act on those two ingredients without waiting for Washington.
Advocates Say New York Missed a Chance
Food safety groups were sharply critical of the veto. They argued that the additives have been linked to cancer and other health concerns, and pointed to restrictions on some of these ingredients in Europe. They also said federal efforts to tighten rules on additives and GRAS ingredients have fallen short.
Jensen Jose, senior regulatory counsel at the Center for Science in the Public Interest, said New York had a chance to lead the nation. He said the veto “hands the food industry a victory at the expense of New York families.” The group had pushed hard for the bill in the Legislature and then lobbied the governor to sign it.
Other States Have Moved Ahead
New York is not the only state that has looked at banning these ingredients. California passed a law that bans several additives, including Red No. 3, propylparaben and potassium bromate, and other states have considered similar bills. The Environmental Working Group keeps an interactive map that tracks state efforts to regulate food chemicals.
Because large food companies sell products nationwide, laws in big states can sometimes lead manufacturers to change recipes everywhere. That is one reason advocates saw New York’s bill as so important. With the veto, the state will not be adding its weight to that push, at least for now.
Could the Bill Come Back?
Supporters say this is not the end of the fight. Jose said he was confident lawmakers would bring the bill back when they return to Albany in January. If they do, it could be rewritten to address some of the cost concerns raised by businesses and the governor’s office.
For now, nothing changes on New York store shelves because of the state bill. Shoppers who want to avoid these additives can check ingredient labels, which list Red No. 3, propylparaben and potassium bromate by name when they are used. Some bakeries and brands also advertise that their products are made without bromated flour.
What This Means for Shoppers
For most families, the veto means business as usual at the grocery store and the corner pizza shop. The bigger change will come in January, when the federal ban on Red No. 3 begins. Products that relied on the dye will need to switch to other colorings, and many companies have already started doing so.
The debate over food additives is likely to keep going in New York and across the country. As more states look at their own rules, shoppers can expect more headlines about what goes into everyday foods. Reading labels remains the simplest way to know exactly what is in the pizza dough, candy or packaged snack you bring home.
