7 Canned Fish That Were Pantry Staples Before Tuna Took Over
Today, when most Americans think of canned fish, they picture a small can of tuna. It goes into sandwiches, casseroles and salads, and it’s been a lunchbox and weeknight staple for generations. But canned tuna wasn’t always the king of the pantry shelf.
Tuna canning in the U.S. only began in 1903, when a cannery owner in San Pedro, California, started packing it after a poor sardine season. Before then, and for decades afterward, American pantries were stocked with a whole range of other canned fish. According to the Star Tribune, tuna didn’t overtake salmon as America’s favorite until around the middle of the 20th century.
Many of the canned fish that once filled Grandma’s cupboard are still sold today, but they’ve become far less common in the average kitchen. Here are seven that were pantry staples long before tuna took over.

1. Canned Salmon
For much of American history, canned salmon was the most popular canned fish in the country. Salmon canning took off in the Pacific Northwest in the late 1800s, and soon tall cans of pink and red salmon were shipped to grocery stores nationwide. It was affordable, filling and full of flavor.
Grandmothers used canned salmon to make salmon croquettes, salmon loaf and creamed salmon on toast. Salmon patties, fried in a skillet and served with a side of peas or mashed potatoes, were a regular Friday supper in many homes, especially among Catholic families who avoided meat that day.
2. Sardines
Small tins of sardines were once found in nearly every pantry, lunch pail and hunting cabin. Maine had a huge sardine industry, and at one point its coast was home to dozens of canneries. Workers packed small herring into flat tins with oil, mustard or tomato sauce.
Over the years, demand dropped, and the canneries closed one by one. According to the state of Maine, the last sardine cannery in the U.S., in Prospect Harbor, closed in 2010. Sardines are still sold, mostly imported, but they’re no longer the everyday food they once were for working families.
3. Mackerel
Canned mackerel was a pantry staple in many Southern and rural households. It was usually cheaper than salmon and had a rich, strong flavor that stood up well to frying. Mackerel patties, made with cornmeal or crackers, onion and egg, were a beloved budget meal.
Many people who grew up in the South still remember the smell of mackerel cakes frying on a weeknight. While canned mackerel can still be found in many stores, it’s often tucked away on a bottom shelf, and younger shoppers may never have tried it.
4. Kippered Herring
Kippers are herring that have been split, salted and smoked, giving them a deep, smoky flavor. They were especially popular among families with British, Scandinavian or Northeastern roots, and they were often eaten for breakfast with eggs and toast.
Small flat tins of kippered herring sat beside sardines on the grocery shelf for decades. They were also a favorite snack for fishermen, hunters and men heading off to work. Today, they’re considered something of an old-fashioned treat, enjoyed mostly by people who grew up with them.
5. Anchovies
Tiny tins of anchovies packed in oil have long been a part of American pantries, especially in Italian-American homes. They were used to add a salty, savory punch to pasta sauces, salad dressings and pizza. Caesar salad dressing, which became popular in the mid-20th century, often relied on them.
Many younger people know anchovies mostly as a pizza topping that gets picked off. But for older home cooks, a tin of anchovies was a secret ingredient that made sauces taste richer, even if nobody at the table could quite tell why.
6. Smoked Oysters
Smoked oysters packed in oil were a popular party food for decades, especially in the 1950s through the 1970s. They were served on crackers at cocktail parties, bridge clubs and holiday gatherings, often alongside a cheese ball and a tray of olives.
These little tins felt a bit fancy, even though they weren’t very expensive. Many families kept a tin or two in the pantry for unexpected company. While they’re still sold, they’ve largely been replaced at parties by charcuterie boards and fancier appetizers.
7. Canned Clams
Canned minced and chopped clams were a staple for many home cooks, especially in New England and coastal areas. They made it possible to whip up clam chowder, clam dip or linguine with clam sauce without a trip to the fish market.
Clam dip made with cream cheese and canned clams was a classic party snack in the mid-20th century. Today, canned clams are still sold, but many shoppers walk right past them on their way to the tuna.
Why These Fish Were So Popular
These canned fish had a lot going for them. They were shelf-stable at a time when not every home had a reliable refrigerator, and they could be stored for months in a cool pantry. They were also cheaper than fresh fish, which was hard to find in many inland towns.
During the Great Depression and the rationing years of World War II, canned fish helped families stretch their food budgets. A single can of salmon or mackerel, mixed with crackers and egg, could feed a whole family. Many grandmothers kept a few cans on hand at all times.
How Tuna Won the Pantry
Tuna’s rise was driven by a combination of factors. It had a mild flavor that appealed to people who didn’t like strong, fishy tastes. It was packed in convenient cans and heavily advertised by brands that became household names. Tuna salad sandwiches and tuna noodle casserole became fixtures of the American kitchen, much like many of the classic casseroles of the era.
As tuna took center stage, many of the stronger-flavored canned fish slowly lost their place. Families who had once eaten salmon patties and sardines on crackers turned to tuna for most of their canned-fish needs.
A Comeback in the Making?
Interestingly, some of these older canned fish are finding new fans. Food writers and younger cooks have rediscovered sardines, mackerel and anchovies as flavorful, affordable foods, and specialty “tinned fish” shops have popped up in some cities. Fancy imported tins now sell for surprisingly high prices.
For people who grew up with these foods, though, they never really went out of style. Which of these canned fish did your family keep in the pantry? And do you still make salmon or mackerel patties the way your mother or grandmother did?
