8 Foods to Think Twice About Ordering at a Diner
A good diner is a small miracle: hot coffee, a griddle that never cools down and a menu long enough to read like a paperback. That long menu is also the catch.
No kitchen can make 150 items from scratch, so chefs say some dishes are far more likely to come from a can, a jar or the freezer. Here are eight to think twice about, based on what chefs have told named food outlets, plus what to order instead.

1. The Soup of the Day
Unless a diner is known for its soup, chefs are skeptical. “Unless soup is one of their specialties, most diners just use the canned stuff,” chef Heloise Blaure told Business Insider.
Gordon Ramsay has a simple test, as noted by The Takeout: ask what yesterday’s soup of the day was. If the answer matches today’s, the pot may have been around a while. If the soup is homemade and the server lights up describing it, go for it. A good bowl of bean or vegetable soup is one of those humble foods even wealthy people happily eat, so it’s worth getting right.
2. Spaghetti or Ziti With Red Sauce
Diners are built around the griddle and the fryer, not the pasta pot. Blaure warned that if you order spaghetti or ziti, you should “be prepared for it to come dressed in store-bought sauce.”
It can also cost about as much as a burger that the kitchen makes far better. Jarred sauce is one of those shortcuts most of us use at home anyway, right alongside these kitchen mistakes we’re all guilty of, so save the pasta craving for an Italian spot.
3. The House Salad
Chef Nick Liberato, host of Netflix’s “Restaurants on the Edge,” told Business Insider that diner salads are usually made with precut produce and mass-produced dressing.
Chef Suhum Jang of Hortus NYC has made a similar point about restaurant salads in general, noting that heavy dressings can cover for tired greens, according to The Takeout. If you want something fresh, a side of sliced tomatoes or fruit is usually a safer bet than the house salad.
4. Fish at a Diner Far From the Coast
Seafood is where chefs get the most cautious about quality. Liberato said smaller diners may not get fresh fish every day, adding, “It’s unlikely to be fresh-caught.” Chef Colin Smith of Smith and River in Reno told Eat This, Not That! that fish at budget restaurants “likely isn’t fresh and the quality is going to be suspect.”
There are exceptions. A seaside diner in New England frying up local clams is a different story. Seafood also turns up on plenty of lists of unconventional American delicacies, but the inland diner fish fry isn’t usually where it shines.
5. Eggs Benedict
It’s a weekend favorite, but hollandaise is tricky to keep right during a rush. Chef Maricel Gentile of Maricel’s Kitchen told Eat This, Not That! that unless a restaurant is very good, the sauce may be “a pre-made ‘canned’ hollandaise or mix.”
Chef Clifton Dickerson of the Auguste Escoffier School of Culinary Arts told The Takeout that “hollandaise sauce is temperamental, especially during a busy brunch rush.” At a diner, two eggs over easy with crispy hash browns is the move. Here’s the one thing diners do to make hash browns so crispy.

6. The Steak Dinner
Diner steaks are often thinner, cheaper cuts. Chef Luke Shaffer of the Auguste Escoffier School of Culinary Arts, also speaking to The Takeout, questioned paying a markup for steak that isn’t “exponentially better than what I can do” at home. Chef Chris Martin told Eat This, Not That! that cheap steak can be “bottom-of-the-barrel.”
If you want beef, order the patty melt or the chicken-fried steak, which is built for the griddle and the gravy boat. Chefs have similar warnings about the worst things to order at a steakhouse, too.
7. Fried Calamari and Frozen Appetizer Platters
Fried calamari on a diner menu often starts out in the freezer, and chefs aren’t fans. Celebrity chef Kai Chase told Eat This, Not That! that frozen calamari tends to come out “tough, chewy,” often served with store-bought sauce.
Onion rings or a basket of fries made in-house will almost always give you more for your money. Ask the server which sides are hand-cut.
8. A Daily Special That Seems Too Cheap
Specials can be wonderful, especially seasonal ones. But Bryce Norblom of the Escoffier School of Culinary Arts offered Eat This, Not That! a simple rule for bargain specials: “If it’s too good (aka cheap) to be true, it probably is.”
A good sign is a special the regulars are ordering. A rotating special that never seems to rotate is another story.
What to Order Instead
Chefs generally agree that diners are best at the things they cook all day: eggs, pancakes, burgers, patty melts, grilled cheese, hash browns and pie. Stick to what the griddle does best, and you’ll rarely be disappointed.
