8 Store-Brand Peanut Butters Ranked From Worst to Best
A lower price can get a peanut butter jar into your cart, but flavor and texture determine whether you buy it again. Across these eight store brands, the useful differences include sweetness, spreadability, jar size, and formulation. Some have independent tasting notes; others have clearer label information than flavor evidence.
This comparison covers sweetened, stabilized creamy products and one clearly labeled no-stir spread. It draws on retailer listings and published reviews, rather than a personal taste test. Prices were checked October 13, 2026, and may differ by location or ordering channel.
Great Value Creamy Peanut Butter
Walmart’s Great Value was listed at $1.94 for 16 ounces, approximately 12.1 cents per ounce. Its ingredients include dry-roasted peanuts, sugar, hydrogenated vegetable oil, salt, and molasses.
That gives shoppers a documented price and formulation to compare with neighboring jars. The tasting verdict is less settled. Allrecipes found it smooth but sticky and considered the flavor bland.
Southern Living’s July 2026 test placed Great Value second overall. Different evaluations produced different conclusions, so neither supports calling it a universal winner or loser.
Related: Top 10 Best Peanut Butter Brands of 2026
Good & Gather Creamy Peanut Butter
Target’s conventional Good & Gather creamy was listed at $1.99 for 16 ounces, about 12.4 cents per ounce. The ingredients include dry-roasted peanuts, sugar, hydrogenated vegetable oils, molasses, mono- and diglycerides, and salt.
Check the name carefully because Target also sells separate organic formulations. Allrecipes offered favorable observations, describing this version as thick, smooth, creamy, and well-seasoned, with less stickiness than several competitors.
These findings make it a useful option for shoppers who prioritize texture. They remain one reviewer’s assessment, without a matched baking or sauce test establishing broader superiority.
Peanut Delight Creamy Peanut Butter
Aldi’s Peanut Delight creamy appeared in an official shopping result at $1.75 for 18 ounces, approximately 9.7 cents per ounce. The listing didn’t provide enough context to determine whether that was ordinary or promotional pricing.
Its current official ingredient label is also still unresolved. The tasting evidence points to a preference for sweetness over roast. Daily Meal found it smoother and more spreadable than Aldi’s separate no-stir version, while noting that sweetness reduced some roasted-peanut character.
Allrecipes likewise described a thick, smooth texture but disliked its sweetness. Whether that sounds appealing depends on what you want from the jar.
Kroger Creamy Peanut Butter
Kroger’s conventional creamy was listed at $2.29 for 16 ounces, roughly 14.3 cents per ounce. That observation came from the displayed Harrisonburg, Virginia, store context, where pickup was available.
It should not be treated as a price guaranteed throughout Kroger’s footprint. The official ingredients include roasted peanuts, sugar, molasses, fully hydrogenated vegetable oils, and salt.
Suitable current comparative tasting evidence was not established for this exact product. Its resemblance to other ingredient lists cannot tell shoppers whether its flavor, stickiness, or sandwich performance will match theirs.
Publix Creamy Peanut Butter
The Publix creamy listing identifies a 40-ounce jar. The retailer’s ingredient information lists roasted peanuts, sugar, hydrogenated vegetable oil, molasses, and salt.
Shoppers should confirm that information against the label on the exact jar they purchase. A verified price and useful current comparative tasting notes were not recovered. That limits what can fairly be said about its value or eating experience.
Its larger package provides a concrete point of comparison, but size alone does not establish savings without the local shelf price.
Signature SELECT Peanut Butter Creamy
Signature SELECT’s creamy peanut butter comes in a documented 16-ounce package and has an official ingredient list. It contains dry-roasted peanuts, sugar, hydrogenated vegetable oil, salt, and molasses.
The Safeway listing requires location-specific shopping context for a useful local price check. No sufficiently matched tasting evidence was established. That leaves flavor and practical spreadability open rather than demonstrating a weakness.
If you compare this jar with another conventional creamy product, use the current label and unit price instead of assuming similar ingredients guarantee the same experience.
Hill Country Fare Creamy Peanut Butter
H-E-B’s Hill Country Fare creamy was listed at $3.98 for 40 ounces in the Victoria H-E-B Plus! context. That works out to approximately 10 cents per ounce. H-E-B cautions that prices can vary by shopping channel.
Its ingredients include peanuts, sugar, fully hydrogenated vegetable oils, salt, molasses, and monoglycerides. The retailer suggests sandwich and baking uses, but those suggestions are not independent performance tests.
The documented unit price is useful; retailer descriptions of smoothness or roasted flavor should not be treated as an unsupported tasting verdict.
365 Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, No Stir
Whole Foods’ 365 no-stir product is specifically labeled a peanut butter spread. Its 16-ounce jar contains dry-roasted peanuts, cane sugar, palm oil, salt, and molasses. The official page expressly states that stirring is unnecessary.
That formulation deserves its own evaluation. Favorable notes about another sweetened 365 product were not securely matched to this exact current version, and tests of unsweetened 365 jars do not transfer automatically. A verified local price was also unavailable, so we couldn’t reliably compare unit cost.
Compare the Ounces Before Choosing
Package size can change the value calculation. Target also displayed a 40-ounce conventional Good & Gather jar for $3.59, about 9 cents per ounce, below its smaller jar’s unit cost.
Use those figures as shopping snapshots, then check your own shelf. For regular shoppers, that is a useful starting point. Price helps compare value; attributed tasting notes help identify preferences. Neither alone determines which jar you will enjoy most.
Other Posts You May Like
. 6 Delicious Foods Everyone Loves That Were Invented In Hard Times
. 6 Cheap Frozen and Canned Foods That Can Be as Healthy as Fresh Produce
