9 Holiday Foods People Over 60 Say They’ve Stopped Making
For decades, the holiday season meant weeks of cooking and baking for many people who are now over 60. They made dozens of cookies, rolled out pie crusts by the stack, assembled elaborate casseroles and spent entire days in the kitchen preparing for family gatherings. It was a labor of love, and they were proud of every dish.
But as the years have gone by, many have quietly scaled back. Some found that their grown children don’t eat the same foods anymore. Others simply decided they’d earned the right to skip the most time-consuming recipes. And some discovered that the store-bought version was good enough.
None of this means the holidays have lost their magic. For many older adults, cutting back has made the season more enjoyable and less exhausting. Here are nine holiday foods many people over 60 say they’ve stopped making, and why.

1. A Dozen Kinds of Christmas Cookies
Many women who raised families in the 1970s and 1980s remember baking huge batches of Christmas cookies every December. Sugar cookies, gingerbread men, spritz, thumbprints, snickerdoodles and more filled tins all over the house. Some made ten or twelve varieties every year.
Today, many have narrowed it down to one or two family favorites. With smaller households and fewer cookie exchanges, there’s less need for so many kinds. Some still bake with their grandchildren, but on a much smaller scale. Many say they don’t miss the flour-covered kitchen at all.
2. Homemade Fruitcake
Fruitcake was once a holiday tradition in many homes. Grandmothers and mothers would chop candied fruit and nuts, bake the dense loaves weeks ahead and wrap them in brandy-soaked cheesecloth to age until Christmas. It was a serious, time-consuming project.
Many people over 60 say they stopped making fruitcake because nobody in the family really ate it. The younger generations often turned up their noses at it, and the jokes about regifted fruitcakes didn’t help. Some still buy a small loaf for nostalgia, but few bake it from scratch anymore.
3. Gelatin Molds
Molded gelatin salads were a centerpiece of holiday tables for decades. Lime Jell-O with pineapple, cranberry gelatin with walnuts and festive layered molds in red and green were standard fare in the 1960s and 1970s. Many people over 60 grew up eating them and made them for their own families.
These days, gelatin molds have largely fallen out of fashion. Many grandchildren don’t like them, and people over 60 say they finally gave themselves permission to stop. A few still make a nostalgic version for the oldest relatives, but it’s no longer a must.
4. Homemade Pie Crust
Making pie crust from scratch was once a point of pride. Many women learned it from their mothers and could roll out a flaky crust without measuring. Every holiday meant several pies, each with a homemade crust.
Today, many people over 60 rely on store-bought crusts instead. They say the quality has improved, and the time saved is worth it. Some still make the filling from scratch, but they no longer wrestle with chilled dough and rolling pins. It’s one of the most common shortcuts older cooks say they’ve embraced. These Thanksgiving pies are still on tables across America.
5. Mincemeat Pie
Mincemeat pie was a holiday staple for earlier generations. Made with dried fruits, spices, apples and sometimes meat or suet, it was rich and old-fashioned. Many people over 60 remember their grandparents loving it.
As those grandparents passed on, mincemeat pie often went with them. Many people over 60 say they stopped making it because nobody else in the family wanted it. It’s become one of the rarest holiday desserts today, mostly found in nostalgic family gatherings.
6. Elaborate Christmas Dinners
For many years, people now over 60 cooked huge Christmas dinners with a roast, a ham, several sides, homemade rolls and multiple desserts. The meal often took days to prepare and fed a crowd of relatives.
Many have since simplified. Some now make a smaller meal or host a casual buffet. Others have passed the holiday dinner on to their adult children. Some even order a prepared holiday meal from a grocery store or restaurant. They say the time with family matters more than the size of the spread.
7. Homemade Candy
Fudge, divinity, peanut brittle and other homemade candies were once a big part of the holiday season. Many people over 60 spent hours stirring pots of sugar syrup and testing them with candy thermometers.
Today, many have cut back on candy-making. It’s labor-intensive, and some recipes, like divinity, can fail on a humid day. Many now buy a box of nice chocolates or make one easy candy, like microwave fudge. They say the stress of candy-making just isn’t worth it anymore.
8. Oyster Stuffing and Other Old Family Recipes
Some families had old-fashioned recipes that were passed down for generations, like oyster stuffing, creamed onions or chestnut dressing. Many people over 60 made them faithfully for years to honor their parents and grandparents.
But as tastes changed, some of these dishes stopped being eaten. People over 60 say they finally let them go when the leftovers kept piling up. Some have written the recipes down for posterity, even if they no longer make them. It’s a way to keep the memories without the work.
9. Homemade Eggnog
Homemade eggnog was once a festive tradition in many households. It was made with eggs, milk, cream, sugar and nutmeg, often with a splash of rum or bourbon for the adults. Some families made big batches for holiday parties.
Many people over 60 have switched to store-bought eggnog, which is easy to find in the dairy case every season. It’s convenient, and it saves time. Some still make homemade eggnog for special occasions, but most say the carton works just fine. Here’s a look at other classic holiday drinks families have enjoyed over the years.
Why They’ve Cut Back
There are many reasons people over 60 have stopped making certain holiday foods. Smaller families, changing tastes and the physical demands of cooking all play a part. Many simply want to enjoy the holidays rather than spend them in the kitchen.
Some also say they’ve realized the holidays aren’t about perfection. A simpler meal, store-bought cookies or a smaller dessert table doesn’t make the season any less meaningful. What matters is being together with loved ones. Many older cooks say this has made the holidays feel more joyful than ever.
Keeping the Memories Alive
Even if they’ve stopped making these foods, many people over 60 still cherish the memories behind them. Some share the old recipes with their grandchildren, while others tell stories about the holiday kitchens of their youth. Those memories are a gift in themselves.
Many families also pick one old recipe to keep making each year, just to honor the past. It might be Grandma’s sugar cookies or a special pie. That single dish can carry generations of tradition. Some families even bring out the vintage decorations of Grandma’s house to go with it.
Which holiday foods have you stopped making over the years? And is there one you still make every season, no matter what?
