7 Cuts of Meat Butchers Rarely Sell Anymore
There was a time when a trip to the butcher counter felt like a conversation. Your mother or grandmother knew the butcher by name, and he knew exactly how she liked her roast trimmed. The case was filled with cuts that today’s shoppers might not even recognize, from tongue and heart to soup bones wrapped in white paper.
Walk into most supermarkets now and the meat case looks very different. It’s mostly boneless chicken breasts, ground beef and a familiar lineup of steaks and pork chops, all sealed in plastic. Many of the cuts that once fed American families on a budget have quietly faded away, or moved to specialty shops and ethnic markets.
Some of these cuts disappeared because tastes changed. Others vanished because they took time to cook, and families stopped having that time. Here are the cuts of meat butchers rarely sell anymore, and why they’ve become so hard to find.

1. Veal
In the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s, veal was a regular part of the American dinner table. Veal cutlets, veal Parmesan, breaded veal patties and veal scallopini were common in both home kitchens and restaurants. Many families ate it every week.
Today, it’s a rare sight in most grocery stores. Veal consumption fell sharply over the decades, partly because of rising prices and partly because of public concern over how calves were raised. According to USDA data, by 2014 Americans were eating only about a pound of veal and lamb combined per person each year. For a lot of younger shoppers, veal is something they’ve only seen on an Italian restaurant menu.
2. Mutton
Mutton, the meat from an older sheep, was once common in America. Colonial and 19th-century cooks used it in stews, roasts and pies, and it was a familiar sight in butcher shops. Over the 20th century, though, it nearly disappeared from American tables.
There are a few theories about why. One popular story holds that soldiers ate so much canned mutton during World War II that they came home never wanting to see it again. Modern Farmer notes that the decline also had a lot to do with economics, as the beef industry simply grew faster and bigger. Today, most sheep meat sold in the U.S. is lamb, and true mutton is mostly found at specialty farms and international markets.
3. Beef Tongue
Ask someone over 70 about beef tongue, and you might hear a story about Sunday supper or a cold tongue sandwich on rye. Grandmothers simmered tongue for hours with onions and spices, then peeled it and sliced it thin. It was tender, inexpensive and stretched to feed a family for several meals.
These days, beef tongue rarely shows up in a standard grocery store meat case. It’s still popular in Mexican cooking, where it’s known as lengua and is served in tacos, and in Jewish delis, where pickled tongue has a loyal following. But for most American shoppers, it has become an unfamiliar cut, and many would never think to buy it.
4. Calf’s Liver
Liver and onions was a classic weeknight dinner for generations. Many baby boomers have vivid memories of it, and not always happy ones. Mothers fried slices of calf’s liver in bacon fat or butter, smothered them in onions and served the dish with mashed potatoes.
You can still find frozen beef liver in some stores, but fresh calf’s liver has become hard to track down. It was always a polarizing dish, and as fewer families cooked it, fewer stores bothered to stock it. Liver and onions still turns up on some diner menus, especially at older diners that cater to longtime regulars, but it’s far from the everyday dinner it once was.
5. Beef Heart
Beef heart is another cut that once appeared at the butcher counter regularly. Thrifty cooks during the Great Depression and World War II made the most of every part of the animal, and heart was cheap and filling. It was often stuffed, braised or sliced and pan-fried.
These days, beef heart is mostly a specialty item. You might find it at a local butcher, a farmers market or a Latin American grocery, where it’s used in dishes like Peruvian anticuchos. Most mainstream supermarkets don’t carry it at all. It’s a good example of the Depression-era foods that once kept families going and have since slipped out of sight.
6. Plain Soup Bones
There was a time when butchers practically gave away soup bones. Grandma would ask for a few beef bones, sometimes with bits of meat still attached, and use them to make broth, vegetable beef soup or a pot of beans. They cost next to nothing, and some butchers threw them in for free with a regular order.
Today, soup bones have mostly been replaced by cartons of broth on the grocery shelf. When bones do show up, they’re often sold as pricier “marrow bones” or “bone broth bones,” a sign of how the times have changed. The humble paper-wrapped soup bone that once flavored a week of meals has become surprisingly hard to find at a bargain price.
7. The Old Steak Names
Some cuts haven’t vanished so much as changed their names. Older shoppers remember steaks like the Delmonico, the club steak and the minute steak. Those names were once printed on labels and spoken at butcher counters across the country.
Today, much of that same meat is sold under different names, such as ribeye, strip steak or thin-sliced round. The Delmonico name in particular has been used for several different cuts over the years, which only added to the confusion. If you ask a young butcher for a club steak, there’s a good chance you’ll get a puzzled look.
Why These Cuts Faded
The decline of these cuts has a lot to do with how Americans cook now. Many old-fashioned cuts need long, slow cooking, and busy families tend to reach for quick-cooking boneless meats. Supermarkets also stopped employing as many in-store butchers, so meat arrives already cut and packaged, which leaves less room for unusual cuts.
Changing tastes play a part too. Younger generations grew up on chicken breasts and burgers, not tongue and heart. Still, some of these cuts are enjoying a quiet comeback among chefs and home cooks who appreciate their flavor and value. Which of these cuts did your family eat growing up, and would you ever buy one today?
