6 Reasons Dating Apps Are Making Americans Give Up on Finding Love
Finding love online sounds simple enough. Download an app, create a profile, swipe through a few interesting people, and hopefully meet someone special. But for many Americans, the reality of modern dating looks very different.
Instead of excitement, some users are finding themselves dealing with endless conversations, disappointing matches, ghosting, and uncomfortable encounters.
A 2024 Forbes Health survey of 1,000 Americans who had used dating apps within the previous year found that 78% sometimes, often, or always experienced emotional, mental, or physical exhaustion from using them.
That is a striking number, especially for something designed to help people connect. The problem is not necessarily that people have stopped believing in love. For some, the process of finding it has simply become exhausting.
Here are six reasons dating apps are leaving Americans frustrated with modern dating.
Finding a Match Doesnāt Mean Finding a Real Connection

Getting a match can feel exciting, particularly when someone appears to share your interests and relationship goals. Unfortunately, that excitement does not always translate into a meaningful connection.
According to the Forbes Health survey, 40% of respondents identified the inability to find a good connection as a reason for dating-app exhaustion. Another 35% pointed to disappointment in people.
This can be frustrating for someone genuinely looking for a long-term relationship. You might match with several people, exchange introductions and even arrange a date, only to discover that the chemistry is missing.
The problem is that having access to more potential partners does not automatically mean finding someone compatible. After enough disappointing experiences, even opening the app can start feeling like an exercise in frustration.
Dating Starts Feeling Like Another Job
Between updating photographs, writing an interesting biography, swiping through profiles, and keeping conversations alive, online dating can demand more time than people initially expect.
The Forbes Health survey found that respondents spent an average of nearly 51 minutes daily on dating apps. Repetitive conversations contributed to exhaustion for 24%, while swiping was another source of frustration for 22%.
It is easy to understand why. Imagine finishing a long day at work, opening your dating app, and realizing you have several unanswered conversations waiting. You feel obligated to respond, introduce yourself to someone new, and keep another conversation going.
Clinical psychologist Sabrina Romanoff told Forbes Health, āDating apps can very easily feel like a second job if youāre not careful about setting time and emotional boundaries around using them.ā
When something intended to make meeting people easier begins competing with work, hobbies, and personal time, taking a break can become increasingly appealing.
Ghosting Makes It Harder to Keep Investing Emotionally
Few modern dating experiences are as frustrating as having a promising conversation suddenly disappear.
You might spend days exchanging messages with someone, discuss your interests, and begin thinking that something worthwhile could develop. Then, without warning, the person stops responding.
This is commonly known as ghosting, and it is not an uncommon experience among dating-app users. The Forbes Health survey found that 41% of respondents had experienced ghosting.
Certified sex therapist Rufus Tony Spann also told Forbes Health that clients describe situations involving people who swipe without communicating, approach them only for sex, or begin conversations before eventually disappearing.
Repeated experiences like these can make people hesitant to become emotionally invested in someone new. Eventually, starting another conversation may feel less exciting because users are already wondering how long it will last.
Too Little Attention or Too Much Can Be Discouraging
One interesting thing about online dating is that people can become frustrated for completely different reasons.
Some users struggle to receive messages, while others feel overwhelmed by the number of people trying to contact them. Neither experience necessarily makes finding a suitable partner easier.
A Pew Research Center study found that 55% of people who had used dating sites or apps within the previous year had at least sometimes felt insecure because of the lack of messages they received. Meanwhile, 36% said they felt overwhelmed by the number of messages coming their way.
The differences between men and women were also notable. Sixty-four percent of men reported feeling insecure because of receiving too few messages, compared with 40% of women. On the other hand, 54% of women felt overwhelmed by messages, compared with 25% of men.
A quiet inbox can leave someone questioning their appeal, while a crowded one can make it difficult to decide who deserves attention. Either way, the experience can become another source of frustration.
Endless Options Can Make People More Likely to Reject Potential Partners
Having hundreds of profiles available might seem like an advantage. After all, more options should mean better chances of finding someone compatible, right? Not necessarily.
Research by Tila Pronk and Jaap Denissen, published in Social Psychological and Personality Science in 2020, examined how having too many choices affects online dating decisions.
Across three studies, the researchers found that participants became increasingly likely to reject potential partners as they moved through available options. They reported an average 27% decrease in the likelihood of acceptance from the first partner option to the last.
The researchers described this behavior as a rejection mindset. The findings suggest that constantly evaluating new profiles can influence how people approach potential partners. Instead of focusing on the person they are considering, users may become more focused on what else could be available.
Of course, this experimental research does not establish that all dating-app users behave this way. Still, it offers an interesting explanation for why endless choices do not always produce greater satisfaction.
Dishonest Profiles and Suspected Scammers Make Trust Difficult
Trust is an important part of any relationship, but establishing it can be difficult when your first interaction with someone happens through a screen.
A profile might contain misleading photographs, inaccurate personal details, or information that makes someone appear more available for a relationship than they actually are.
According to Pew Research Center, 52% of people who had ever used a dating site or app believed they had encountered someone trying to scam them.
Dishonesty is another concern. In the Forbes Health survey, 21% of respondents admitted lying about their age, while 13% admitted lying about their current relationship status.
These experiences can make people more cautious about who they trust. Someone who has previously encountered misleading information may feel the need to verify even basic details before becoming emotionally invested.
Neuropsychologist Judy Ho told Forbes Health, āYou donāt know how much you should invest emotionally, and then sometimes when you do, you get burned, so it makes you more cynical for the next interaction.ā
After several disappointing encounters, approaching someone new with an open mind can become increasingly difficult.
